Sunday
December 21, 1856
New-York dispatch (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“Buchanan Lost the Popular Vote in 1856—And Nobody Knew What to Do About It”
Art Deco mural for December 21, 1856
Original newspaper scan from December 21, 1856
Original front page — New-York dispatch (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The New-York Dispatch publishes its weekly edition on December 21, 1856, a pivotal moment in American history just four years before the Civil War. The paper's "Notes and Queries" section dominates the front page, fielding reader questions on everything from meteorology to maritime physics to the mechanics of Samuel Morse's telegraph system. One particularly charged query addresses the recent presidential election: a correspondent asks about James Buchanan's popular vote total, and the Dispatch confirms that Buchanan did NOT win a popular majority—he received 1,600,304 votes compared to John C. Frémont's 1,338,247 and Millard Fillmore's 785,208. This was the explosive 1856 election that saw the young Republican Party (backing Frémont) nearly unseat the Democrat Buchanan, a result that foreshadowed the sectional crisis to come. The paper also discusses New York's voter registration law of 1841, passed under Whig Governor William H. Seward, and its unexpected repeal just a year later when Democrats won using it—a reminder of how partisan this era had become.

Why It Matters

December 1856 was America holding its breath. Buchanan's election had just been decided, and while he won the presidency, his lack of a popular majority exposed deep fractures. The Republican Party's strong showing—especially Frémont's appeal in Northern states—signaled that slavery and westward expansion were tearing the nation apart. William H. Seward, mentioned in the Dispatch's voter registration discussion, would become Lincoln's Secretary of State and a leading Republican voice. The very act of debating voter registration and state sovereignty in this paper reflects how fragile consensus had become. Every legal question, every state's rights debate, every sectional reference carried weight. This newspaper captures a moment when Americans were still trying to solve their deepest conflicts through law and elections—just four years before they stopped trying.

Hidden Gems
  • The Dispatch charges 10 cents per line for regular advertisements, with a special rate of 12½ cents for 'Special Notices'—meaning mid-19th century New York papers had sophisticated tiered pricing structures for different ad types, much like digital media today.
  • A reader named 'Ariosto' engages in a sophisticated constitutional debate about state sovereignty and divorce law, arguing that South Carolina's refusal to recognize out-of-state divorces proves states DO see themselves as sovereign entities—a prescient argument about federalism on the eve of secession.
  • The paper includes a detailed thermometrical register for the week ending December 20, showing temperatures ranging from 15°F to 58°F, with daily highs and lows meticulously recorded at the Dispatch office—essentially a Victorian version of a weather app.
  • A correspondent asks who invented pins, and the Dispatch admits uncertainty but notes pins weren't introduced to England until 1513, before which 'ladies of Britain were compelled to use pins without heads, formed of ivory and silver'—a fascinating detail about pre-modern fashion logistics.
  • The paper recommends 'the house of White Storms, 59 Wall street' as a reliable financial firm, specifically praising their restraint in speculation—one of countless warnings about reckless market behavior that would eventually lead to financial crashes.
Fun Facts
  • The Dispatch prints a detailed explanation of Samuel Morse's telegraph system, describing how operators 'elevate the iron pen' to open circuits and 'depress' it to send messages—this was cutting-edge technology in 1856, yet the paper explains it as casually as we might explain email today.
  • James Buchanan, mentioned in the election results discussion, would become one of the most reviled presidents in American history for his inaction during the secession crisis that immediately followed this very election. The Dispatch's readers didn't yet know they'd elected the man many historians blame for allowing the Union to split.
  • William H. Seward, the Whig governor credited with the voter registration law, went on to purchase Alaska from Russia in 1867—a deal so mocked at the time ('Seward's Folly') that it nearly ended his career, yet it doubled U.S. territory. The man making voting law history in 1841 would make geopolitical history a quarter-century later.
  • The paper discusses Paul Jones (John Paul Jones), the Revolutionary naval commander, noting he 'died in poverty at Paris, in 1792'—yet by 1905, his remains were retrieved from France and given a state funeral at the Naval Academy, finally honoring a hero long forgotten.
  • The Dispatch's meteorological debate about temperature changes before rain reflects genuine scientific uncertainty in 1856—these readers are engaging with cutting-edge physics, yet we wouldn't understand the mechanisms of atmospheric pressure systems for decades. They were thinking like scientists without the full picture.
Anxious Civil War Election Politics Federal Legislation Science Technology Weather
December 20, 1856 December 22, 1856

Also on December 21

1836
The Day Before the Crash: A Washington Capital Booming (and Breaking) in 1836
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
A Cabinet Secretary's Brutal Diagnosis: America's Consular System Is a Mess...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
War With Britain? The Trent Affair Nearly Ended the Union—Here's How Close We...
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
1862
Lincoln's Cabinet Explodes: How America Nearly Got a Military Dictator...
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1864
100 Guns Fired for Thomas's Victory—The War's Turning Point Arrives in Cleveland
Cleveland morning leader (Cleveland [Ohio])
1865
Dec 21, 1865: Senator's Fiery Speech Exposes Post-War Southern Violence
New-York daily tribune (New-York [N.Y.])
1866
Lincoln's Assassins Seek Freedom While Congress Battles Over the South's Future...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
How 1876 Maine Farmers Turned Swamps Into Gold—And Why Their Vinegar Tasted...
The Republican journal (Belfast, Me.)
1886
December 21, 1886: When Kentucky Avenue Was Just a Cow Path—And Other Capital...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
Death Comes Four Ways to Maine: When One Small State's Monday Got Dark
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1906
When Oregon Fined Bankers $35,000 for Missing Paperwork (and Other 1906...
The Oregon mist (St. Helens, Columbia County, Or.)
1926
27 frozen bodies, a baseball bombshell, and Uncle Sam's postcard fiasco: Dec...
The Washington daily news (Washington, D.C.)
1927
The 'Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde' Murderer Still Free: Inside the Marian Parker...
New Britain herald (New Britain, Conn.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free