Wednesday
December 10, 1856
The Evansville daily journal (Evansville, Ia. [i.e. Ind.]) — Vanderburgh, Evansville
“Coal Oil, Moral Panic & Bloody Politics: What Evansville Read on December 10, 1856”
Art Deco mural for December 10, 1856
Original newspaper scan from December 10, 1856
Original front page — The Evansville daily journal (Evansville, Ia. [i.e. Ind.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Evansville Daily Journal's December 10, 1856 front page leads with a harrowing moral sermon titled "The Drunkard's Death," a vivid and deeply uncomfortable meditation on a dying alcoholic's final moments. The piece spares no grotesque detail—bloodshot eyes, parched lips, the "very personification of ruin"—and concludes with a chilling biblical warning: "All drunkards shall have their portion in the lake that burneth with fire and brimstone." Below this fire-and-brimstone warning, the paper covers a brewing scandal between two prominent political figures, Burlingame and Brooks, with speculation that Brooks may attempt "dire revenge" or even assassination over past humiliation. The paper also reports on an emerging industrial marvel: Breckenridge Coal Oil, a new petroleum-based lamp fuel that burns as brightly as whale oil but without the smell, and can be used in ordinary camphene lamps. A tragedy rounds out the front section: a four-year-old girl from Powell's Mills drowned in a mill pond while gathering wildflowers, which were clutched in her hand even as her body was recovered.

Why It Matters

This December 1856 snapshot captures America at a moral and political inflection point. The temperance movement was gaining steam, and newspapers wielded tremendous power as moral guardians, not just news outlets—hence the apocalyptic tone of the drunkard sermon. Simultaneously, the Burlingame-Brooks affair reflects the escalating sectional tensions and personal violence that would define the 1850s; these were not abstract political disagreements but intensely personal feuds that sometimes ended in bloodshed. The coal oil item hints at an industrial transformation already underway—America's vast petroleum reserves were beginning to reshape energy and commerce, even as most readers still depended on whale oil and candles. These three elements—moral panic, political violence, and technological disruption—were the undercurrents pulling the nation toward the Civil War.

Hidden Gems
  • The paper advertises Breckenridge Coal Oil as superior to whale oil, yet notes that people mistakenly believe a 'lamp of peculiar construction' is required—it actually works in ordinary camphene lamps. This hints at how transformative and confusing new technology felt to ordinary Americans in the 1850s.
  • A local ad announces that William Boyler & Co.'s foundry has purchased the business of a predecessor and now offers iron work 'at short notice'—a direct appeal to railroad expansion, which was the era's dominant infrastructure boom.
  • Dr. Hitchcock's geological discourse, reprinted in the paper, uses fossil evidence to argue that man appeared far later on earth than other animals. In 1856, this was cutting-edge (and controversial) science being debated in the press, years before Darwin's Origin of Species would ignite the evolution wars.
  • The Vincennes Gazette reports that Mr. Tripp, who manages railroad track between Vincennes and Evansville, was brutally assaulted in St. Louis by two robbers wielding slung shots—armed robbery on railroad workers was becoming common enough to warrant newspaper notice.
  • A classifieds section advertises 300 gift books for sale with promotional gifts (watches, eardrops, purses) included with purchase—a 19th-century version of a book club bonus offer, suggesting direct-mail marketing was already a competitive business.
Fun Facts
  • The paper's moral outrage over the drunkard's death reflects a broader temperance crusade that would culminate in Prohibition just 63 years later. Evansville would become famous as a center of whiskey distilling—the very vice the journal condemned—making this front page's moral certainty historically ironic.
  • The Burlingame-Brooks scandal mentioned here likely refers to Matthew C. Burlingame and Preston Brooks, figures caught in the violent politics of Bleeding Kansas. Brooks would later become infamous for caning Senator Charles Sumner in 1856, making this contemporary gossip column a record of pre-Civil War personal feuds.
  • Coal oil (kerosene) was still novel enough in 1856 that the paper felt obliged to explain it works in existing lamps. Within a decade, petroleum extraction would reshape American energy entirely, and the whale oil industry—still dominant in 1856—would collapse by the 1870s.
  • The paper was published at the corner of Main and Water Streets and cost ten cents per week (about $3.50 today). Its emphasis on moral instruction alongside news reflects how 19th-century papers saw themselves as educators, not just informants.
  • The tragedy of the drowned girl is presented with Victorian sentimentality—the wildflowers clutched in her hand as an 'emblem of the pure spirit'—a tone and framing that would feel jarring to modern readers but was standard for the era's treatment of child death.
Anxious Civil War Politics Federal Crime Violent Science Technology Temperance Disaster Industrial
December 9, 1856 December 11, 1856

Also on December 10

1836
For Sale: 50-100 Enslaved People, Child Laborers Wanted—Inside a Richmond...
Richmond enquirer (Richmond, Va.)
1846
Did a Woman Forge Marriage Documents to Steal a General's Fortune? The Van Ness...
American Republican and Baltimore daily clipper (Baltimore, Md.)
1861
Last Call for Order: New Orleans Drills for War (December 1861)
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.])
1862
Inside the Naval Revolution: How the Union Built Three Ironclads in a Single...
Cleveland morning leader (Cleveland [Ohio])
1863
A December 1863 Iowa Newspaper Reveals What Americans Actually Worried About...
Charles City Republican intelligencer (Charles City, Iowa)
1864
Sherman's Unstoppable March: How the South's Own States Started Jumping Ship...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1866
The Last Patriot Still Living: Inside Reconstruction's Most Brutal Week...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
When New Orleans Raced Horses and Ministers Debated Democracy (Dec. 10, 1876)
New Orleans Republican (New Orleans, La)
1886
When Maine Newspapers Sold Arsenic as Medicine (Plus Senate Tariff Wars)
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1896
When a Stonecutter Sued His Union: The Labor War That Started in 1896
The Sioux County journal (Harrison, Nebraska)
1906
When the Pope Defied France & a Brass Button Saved a Cop's Life
New-York tribune (New York [N.Y.])
1926
When Arkansas Freed Two Murderers & Local Hillbillies Hit the Airwaves
The Calico Rock progress ([Calico Rock, Izard County], Ark.)
1927
A Hammer, a Kiss, and the Bootlegger's Trial: Why America Was Obsessed With...
The Indianapolis times (Indianapolis [Ind.])
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free