Monday
November 3, 1856
New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.]) — Orleans, Louisiana
“Election Eve 1856: When New Orleans Held Its Breath—and Got Buchanan”
Art Deco mural for November 3, 1856
Original newspaper scan from November 3, 1856
Original front page — New Orleans daily crescent ([New Orleans, La.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The New Orleans Daily Crescent on November 3, 1856, is dominated by one urgent matter: tomorrow's presidential election. The paper leads with extensive steamboat and railroad schedules—the infrastructure of how voters will travel to cast their ballots across Louisiana, Texas, and Mississippi. "About the time the sun sets in the west tomorrow evening," the editor writes, "the preference of the State of this United States will have been expressed." The paper explicitly endorses Millard Fillmore, the Know Nothing (American) Party candidate, though the editor admits weary ambivalence: "We are heartily tired of political turmoil and excitement." Beyond politics, the front page is packed with commercial life—departures for sea-going vessels headed to Galveston and Matamoras, regular packets on the Mississippi and its tributaries, and hotel advertisements. The paper itself is published daily except Sundays by Nixon Adams at 70 Camp Street, offering readers everything from shipping news to restaurant reviews in a single dense broadsheet.

Why It Matters

This election was the last gasp of the second party system and a harbinger of Civil War. Fillmore's Know Nothing Party, nativist and anti-slavery but non-committal, was collapsing. Democrat James Buchanan would win, carrying the South—a victory that would embolden southern secessionists within four years. Louisiana, where this paper circulated, would secede in 1861. The Democratic dominance in the South reflected growing sectional tension; the Know Nothings' vagueness on slavery satisfied no one in a nation tearing itself apart. The editor's exhaustion captures a real historical moment: Americans were fatigued by the slavery debate that dominated every election and every newspaper, yet unable to escape it. Commerce and steamboats dominate the front page, but the shadow of disunion looms.

Hidden Gems
  • The paper advertises coach fares: travelers could journey from New Orleans by rail, and specific packet boats leaving 'Thursday, November 5th' at P.M. show that election day itself (November 4th) was structured around transportation schedules—voters had to plan their travel days in advance, unlike modern same-day voting.
  • A mysterious classified notices section mentions 'The Watch Store, No. 3 Camp Street'—Gregory Wilson sold watches, compasses, jewelry, guns, and pistols, and notably, 'Old Gold and Silver Bought.' This casual mention of precious metals trading suggests informal financial markets operating from storefronts in an era before banks dominated such transactions.
  • Hotels heavily advertised—the 'St. Charles Hotel' and 'Raymond's Hotel' feature prominently—indicating that election season brought enough travelers to the city that hospitality was a booming business tied directly to political cycles.
  • An ad for 'Goal Chaster Feed' (coal and grain combined) at the corner of Chestnut and Lafayette Streets reveals the intersection of industrial fuel and agricultural supply in a pre-Civil War port city economy.
  • The paper lists steamboat packets with remarkable specificity: 'Upper Mississippi,' 'Red River,' 'Yazoo River,' 'Arkansas River'—showing the Mississippi River system as the literal circulatory system of trade and communication for the entire South and interior.
Fun Facts
  • Millard Fillmore, endorsed by this paper, was a one-term president (1850-1853) whose presidency was defined by the Compromise of 1850. By 1856, running as the Know Nothing candidate, he won only Maryland—the worst result for a major-party candidate until 2016. The Know Nothings' evasion on slavery meant Fillmore appealed to neither camp.
  • The New Orleans Daily Crescent itself was a significant paper—it had a circulation of over 4,000 copies daily, making it one of the South's most influential outlets. Yet within five years, Louisiana papers would be rallying the state toward secession, showing how rapidly American public opinion fractured.
  • The steamboat schedules listed—'Northern Packet,' 'Southern Packet,' 'for Galveston and Matamoras'—reflect the economic lifeline between New Orleans and Mexico. Mexico's proximity (Matamoras is just across the Texas border) and the extensive mercantile ties would factor heavily in Civil War blockade strategies.
  • The election of 1856 was the second and final presidential election contested between three major parties. By 1860, the Know Nothings had evaporated, and Lincoln's Republican Party (founded in 1854) had already replaced them—a seismic political realignment in just four years.
  • The editor's exhaustion with 'political turmoil and excitement' was prescient. Within five years, political excitement would turn into actual military conflict, and newspapers like this would cease to be organs of debate and become instruments of war.
Anxious Election Politics Federal Transportation Maritime Transportation Rail Economy Trade
November 2, 1856 November 4, 1856

Also on November 3

1836
A Boy on the Canal & the Cooking Stove Revolution: Cincinnati 1836
The Daily Cincinnati Republican, and commercial register (Cincinnati, Ohio)
1846
Monterey's Slaughter: How America's War with Mexico Spiraled Into Carnage (1846)
American Republican and Baltimore daily clipper (Baltimore, Md.)
1861
Cannons on the Potomac: Inside the Union's Secret Naval Strike (Nov 3, 1861)
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1862
THE PIRATE ALABAMA IS COMING FOR NEW YORK: How a Confederate Raider Terrorized...
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1863
How to Rub a Fever Away: 1863 Maine's Wildest Medical Advice—Plus Lincoln's...
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1864
Factory Girls, Skeleton Skirts & Ether: Life in a Civil War Mill Town Nobody...
The Willimantic journal (Willimantic, Conn.)
1866
The Morning 3,000 Cretans Drowned & America's Police Commissioners Refused to...
The Evansville journal (Evansville, Ind.)
1876
Inside a Maine Newspaper's Bustling 1876 Marketplace—With a $500 Arson Mystery
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
Liberty's First Day: How a Danish Paper in Nebraska Covered the Statue's...
Stjernen (St. Paul, Howard County, Nebraska)
1896
Election Eve 1896: Rockets, Rumors & The Battle for America's Soul—Both Sides...
The Wichita daily eagle (Wichita, Kan.)
1926
Nov 3, 1926: Democrats Surge, Murder Trial Begins, and Dynamite Rocks Election...
The Alaska daily empire (Juneau, Alaska)
1927
A Panther in the Dark (That Wasn't): How 1927 Marlinton Kept Its Frontier...
Pocahontas times (Huntersville, W. Va.)
View all 12 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free