“September 1856: A River City's Commerce Thrives While America Teeters on the Brink”
What's on the Front Page
The Evansville Daily Journal for Monday, September 22, 1856, is largely devoted to commercial advertising and business announcements—a window into the bustling mercantile life of this Ohio River port city. The front page is dominated by classified ads from local merchants hawking everything from bolts of fabric and machinery to groceries and hardware supplies. Among the prominent notices is a business change announcement from M. W. Foster, who has sold his stock of groceries to Messrs. Z. H. Cook & Sons and is retiring to join the firm of Geo. Foster & Co. The paper also carries advertisements from commission merchants in Louisville and Cincinnati, reflecting Evansville's position in a tight network of Ohio Valley trading hubs. A notice announces the arrival of 'Metropolitan Boots'—a popular style returning for the fall season—while another advertises Wheeler & Wilson's sewing machines as revolutionary devices operating 'upon an entirely new principle' with no shuttle, suitable for both family use and commercial manufacturers.
Why It Matters
This September 1856 edition arrives at a critical moment in American history. Just weeks earlier, the nation had erupted over the caning of Senator Charles Sumner by South Carolina's Preston Brooks—an act of violence that shocked the North and deepened the divide over slavery. While Evansville's commercial press focuses on trade and goods, the election of 1856 loomed, with John C. Frémont's Republican candidacy representing the North's growing opposition to slavery's expansion. Indiana was a crucial border state, and Evansville's position on the Ohio River—the traditional boundary between free and slave territories—made it a microcosm of sectional tension. The everyday commerce on these pages existed against a backdrop of a nation fragmenting over slavery.
Hidden Gems
- The Wheeler & Wilson sewing machine advertisement emphasizes that machines operate with 'no shuttle' and 'one needle and two threads'—revolutionary technology in 1856. These machines were genuinely transformative for manufacturers, and by the 1860s, Wheeler & Wilson would dominate the American sewing machine market before being overtaken by Singer.
- Franklin Reilly's dry goods store advertised 'Mourning Collars and Sleeves' and 'white and black English crape Collars'—specialized mourning wear reflecting the era's elaborate death rituals. Families were expected to wear specific garments for prescribed periods, and retailers maintained dedicated mourning sections.
- The City Hotel, run by W. H. Builcourt, advertised rooms 'between Vine and Division' streets, with no mention of prices—suggesting lodging costs were negotiable or understood by local knowledge, unlike modern standardized hotel pricing.
- An ad for 'Choice Rio Coffee' selling for unspecified prices and 'Choice Brick' tobacco appeared alongside imported goods from Cincinnati and Louisville—Evansville was a transshipment point where luxury items arrived by steamboat and canal.
- The paper cost ten cents per week by carrier or one dollar for daily delivery—meaning an unskilled laborer earning perhaps $1 per day would spend 10% of daily wages on a week's papers, making newspapers a significant household expense.
Fun Facts
- The Evansville Daily Journal lists subscription rates of $1 for daily mail delivery and $4 for tri-weekly service—yet by 1856, the telegraph had already begun transforming news transmission. However, most regional papers still relied on reprinting from distant exchanges, making local papers like this one the only source for Evansville-specific commerce and politics.
- The ad for Platner & Smith's book and newspaper stock in Cincinnati mentions they are 'agents for Clifton and City Mills'—these were actual paper mills in Ohio. The mid-1850s saw the rise of mechanical wood-pulp paper production, which would eventually replace expensive rag-based paper and make newspapers affordable to the masses.
- Z. H. Cook & Sons' grocer advertisement includes a charming rhyming testimonial promising 'flour and sugar, soda, soap' and 'no man, except a stupid sot, can want for oven, pan or pot'—an early example of jingle-based advertising that would flourish in the late 19th century.
- Frank Carter Jewett, a commission merchant in New Orleans, advertised buying Western produce and selling groceries—a reminder that Evansville's economy was deeply tied to Southern commerce despite growing sectional tension. Within five years, this trade network would be severed by Civil War.
- The 'Metropolitan Boots' advertisement promises a style that 'gave such general satisfaction last fall and spring' and is now returning—suggesting seasonal fashion cycles already existed in the 1850s, with manufacturers predicting and recycling popular styles much like modern fashion houses.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free