Friday
July 25, 1856
The Bedford gazette (Bedford, Pa.) — Bedford, Pennsylvania
“1856: When Democrats Offered $1,000 to Prove a Political Lie (And Attacked Frémont's Religion)”
Art Deco mural for July 25, 1856
Original newspaper scan from July 25, 1856
Original front page — The Bedford gazette (Bedford, Pa.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Bedford Gazette's July 25, 1856 front page is consumed by Democratic fervor for the coming presidential election. A rousing poem titled "Ho! Rally Freemen" urges voters to support James Buchanan and running mate John C. Breckinridge, mocking Republicans and their "Know Nothing" allies as fanatics obsessed with abolition. Below the verse, the Democratic County Committee announces a series of township meetings across Bedford County, promising "calm, temperate" discussion and featuring Col. O.C. Harkey from Galveston, Texas as a speaker. But the page's most inflammatory content is a $1,000 reward offer—essentially a challenge—to anyone who can prove Buchanan ever advocated the "10 cent" standard for American labor wages. The Democrats dismiss this as "vile slander" from abolitionists. The front page is then dominated by a scathing anti-Fremont article titled "Fremont is Catholic," which uses Catholic theological documents and Church ritual texts to argue that Republican presidential candidate John C. Frémont must have been a Catholic when he married Jessie Benton before a Catholic priest, Father Van Horseigh, in Washington. The piece meticulously quotes the Council of Trent and Catholic marriage rituals to prove a Protestant could never be married by a Catholic priest without professing the faith—suggesting Frémont has since renounced Catholicism purely for political gain.

Why It Matters

This page captures the white-hot center of American politics in summer 1856, just months before a pivotal election. The nation was fracturing over slavery's expansion into new territories, and the Democratic Party—still dominant—was fighting desperately to hold together its uneasy North-South coalition. Buchanan, a Pennsylvania Democrat, represented the "popular sovereignty" compromise: let territories decide slavery for themselves. Republicans, led by Frémont, opposed slavery's spread. The "Know Nothing" party attacked both, scapegoating Catholics and immigrants. This page reveals how visceral and personal the campaigns were: attacking candidates' religions, inventing charges like the "10 cent wage" slander, deploying theological arguments as political weapons. The religious hysteria against Frémont was part of a broader anti-Catholic nativism that inflamed American politics throughout the 1850s.

Hidden Gems
  • The poem casually rhymes 'niggers' in a campaign verse meant for family newspapers—stark evidence of how openly racist campaign rhetoric was in 1856, even in print.
  • The $1,000 reward for proving Buchanan's '10 cent wage' claim—essentially a bounty on a political lie—shows how Democrats were fighting misinformation with cash incentives, a surprisingly modern political tactic.
  • Father Van Horseigh, the priest who married Frémont, is named as being 'of character and high standing in the church'—yet the article uses his own marriage ceremony as evidence Frémont was Catholic, turning a respected priest's professional act into a political weapon.
  • The article quotes the Council of Trent (1545-1563) and multiple Catholic catechisms verbatim, suggesting Pennsylvanians in 1856 had access to detailed Catholic theological texts—evidence of both sectarian tensions and surprising religious literacy.
  • The Democratic County Committee scheduled 15 township meetings across Bedford County between August 11-22, with names like 'Buxton's Meeting House' and 'Akc's Mill'—a grassroots campaign organization more intensive than many modern efforts.
Fun Facts
  • James Buchanan, the Democrat championed here, would win the 1856 election but become widely regarded as one of America's worst presidents for his failure to prevent the Civil War—validating, ironically, Republican warnings about his weakness on slavery.
  • Frémont's marriage to Jessie Benton in 1841 was genuinely controversial partly because her father, Senator Thomas Hart Benton, was estranged from the family—giving the Catholic priest detail a kernel of truth buried in propaganda. Frémont would lose the 1856 election but became a Union general in the Civil War.
  • The 'Know Nothing' party mentioned here as an enemy of both Democrats and Republicans peaked in 1856—this very year—and would collapse entirely by 1859, making this one of its last moments of national relevance.
  • The poem's author remains anonymous ('Written for the Daily Pennsylvanian'), but the viciousness suggests deep community investment; local newspaper poetry was read aloud in taverns and at gatherings, making this verse a viral political message of its era.
  • Bedford County's schedule of 15 meetings in 42 days represents a level of coordinated, decentralized campaigning that predates modern media—pure retail politics, with Col. Harkey traveling by horse-drawn conveyance to speak at schoolhouses and meeting halls.
Contentious Politics Federal Election Religion Civil Rights
July 24, 1856 July 26, 1856

Also on July 25

1836
Ice Cream Rooms & Slave Auctions: What Washington's Newspapers Revealed About...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1846
Virginia Congressman Calls Out Congress for Shredding the Constitution Over...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
A Wealthy Man's Curse: When a Dagger Becomes a Black Bird (Worcester, 1861)
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1862
"Salt Horse and Skedaddling Rebels: A Connecticut Soldier's Letter from the...
The Willimantic journal (Willimantic, Conn.)
1863
A Harvard Scholar's Last Letter Home: One Month After Gettysburg, Worcester...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1864
Atlanta Trembles as Union Cavalry Crushes Hood's Army—McPherson Falls, But...
The evening telegraph (Philadelphia [Pa.])
1866
Tennessee Returns: Congress Celebrates Readmission While Johnson Sulks (July...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
A Tiger, a Jealous Husband, and a Wife's Desperate Act: What Captivated Maine...
Oxford Democrat (Paris, Me.)
1886
The Scandal That Ended a Star: How Sir Charles Dilke's Fall Reshaped British...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1896
How Rural Louisiana Built Its Roads (Spoiler: One Bridge at a Time, One...
Lake Charles commercial (Lake Charles, Calcasieu Parish, La.)
1906
Revolution, streetcar wars, and a murder trial that shocked America - July 25,...
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
1926
🚂 1926: Texas Celebrates New Railroad as Future VP Wins in Landslide
Brownsville herald (Brownsville, Tex.)
1927
Navy Ace Survives 8-Mile Free Fall; Congressman Dies in Bay—July 25, 1927
The Washington daily news (Washington, D.C.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free