Thursday
June 26, 1856
Weekly Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis [Ind.]) — Indiana, Marion
“1856: Democrats Defend Buchanan Against the 'Black Republicans'—And It Gets Ugly”
Art Deco mural for June 26, 1856
Original newspaper scan from June 26, 1856
Original front page — Weekly Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis [Ind.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Weekly Indiana State Sentinel for June 26, 1856, is consumed with the bitter presidential contest between Democrat James Buchanan and the emerging Republican Party. The paper republishes Horace Greeley's stirring defense of Republican principles from the New York Tribune, then launches a scathing Democratic counterattack, accusing the 'Black Republican party' of adopting Greeley's 'crude radicalisms' on slavery. But the most explosive piece defends Buchanan against an old slander—that he once declared he'd drain any Democratic blood from his veins. The paper publishes a sworn certificate from prominent Lancaster, Pennsylvania citizens, dated 1828, explicitly denying he ever said such a thing. Meanwhile, a separate article defends Buchanan's role in the 1854 Ostend Manifesto, which suggested the U.S. might forcibly seize Cuba from Spain if she refused to sell it. The Democrats argue this was simply diplomacy in service of national interest, not imperialism.

Why It Matters

June 1856 was the fever pitch of American democracy collapsing over slavery. The Republican Party, founded just two years earlier, was nominating its first presidential candidate (John C. Frémont, not yet decided in this edition). Meanwhile, pro-slavery forces in Kansas were literally fighting anti-slavery settlers—'Bleeding Kansas' was happening right then. Buchanan, a Pennsylvania Democrat, represented the party's desperate attempt to hold the Union together through compromise and westward expansion. The Ostend Manifesto, leaked and controversial, revealed how far Democrats would go to extend slavery's reach into the Caribbean. This election would determine whether slavery would expand or contain—a question that would be answered only by civil war four years later.

Hidden Gems
  • The Weekly Sentinel offered a three-tier subscription model: within Marion County was FREE, within Indiana cost $1, and nationwide delivery cost $1.50—reflecting how postage and distribution literally fragmented America's information landscape in 1856.
  • Among the certificate signers attesting to Buchanan's Democratic bona fides is 'Christian Bachular'—possibly Buchanan's own relative—suggesting the campaign was deploying family testimonials to defend against slander.
  • Senator Hamlin's dramatic floor speech withdrawing from the Democratic Party reportedly produced 'enthusiastic cheering' at the Know Nothing Convention in New York, yet the paper notes this was 'singular' since the Know Nothings cared about immigration, not Kansas—revealing how the slavery crisis was swallowing every other political issue.
  • The paper devotes substantial space to Indianapolis boasting of its rapid improvement: 'new buildings are springing up in all parts of the city' and there's been a 'vast increase' in hotel business, suggesting westward growth was fueling economic optimism even as the nation tore itself apart over slavery.
  • A small printing house advertisement boasts of having 'a card press' and offers 'railroad printing' and 'largest posters and show bills'—evidence that even local Indiana printers were competing for lucrative railroad contracts as the rail boom transformed commerce.
Fun Facts
  • The Ostend Manifesto, vigorously defended on this page, was so controversial that it actually damaged Buchanan's presidency when he took office two years later. The leaked diplomatic memo suggesting forcible seizure of Cuba enraged free-soil northerners and made him look like a tool of slavery's expansion—ironic, since the paper claims he was just being practical about national interests.
  • Horace Greeley, the New York Tribune editor whose principles the Democrats attack here as 'visionary' and 'disorganizing,' would himself run for president in 1872—partly because Republicans came to see Lincoln's successor, Grant, as corrupt. Greeley's 1856 Tribune was genuinely radical on slavery, but by 1872 he'd become almost conservative.
  • The paper's bitter mockery of 'Black Republicans' and 'Know Nothings' highlights a baffling moment in American history: in 1856, the Republican Party, Know Nothing Party, and Free Soil Democrats were all competing to replace the collapsing Whig Party. Within four years, the Republicans would be the only viable opposition to Democrats.
  • James Buchanan, being defended here as a lifelong loyal Democrat, would prove to be one of America's most ineffective presidents—widely blamed for inaction as southern states seceded. That certificate of support from Lancaster's elite? It wouldn't save him from historical infamy.
  • The paper's insistence on republishing a 28-year-old certificate from 1828 to refute the 'drop of democratic blood' slander shows how personal character attacks and rumor-mongering, supposedly modern plagues, were absolutely central to 19th-century politics—and how desperately campaigns had to fight them.
Contentious Civil War Politics Federal Election Politics International Civil Rights
June 25, 1856 June 27, 1856

Also on June 26

View all 11 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free