What's on the Front Page
The Weekly Indiana State Sentinel's March 27, 1856 edition is consumed by the roiling national crisis over slavery and western expansion. The paper carries a scathing Senate attack on Charles Robinson, the "Governor elect of Kansas," whom Senator Jones accuses of leading desperados and "ruffians" in California land disputes before appearing in Kansas as champion of "spurious squatter sovereignty." The piece drips with contempt, noting Robinson fled California's legislature and "never appeared there again." Meanwhile, the paper devotes substantial space to Maine's judiciary committee report on repealing that state's prohibitory liquor law—a legal treatise arguing that forbidding citizens from drinking violates natural rights and individual liberty. The report, written by a respected jurist and Bowdoin College professor, claims such laws have "never been permanently and successfully sustained" anywhere in history. Local crime also features: a scandal involving a wealthy Indiana man named Straws who seduced a servant girl, passed her off as his wife to boarding houses, and narrowly avoided bigamy charges when she swore under oath she'd never been married to him.
Why It Matters
This page captures America in 1856—a nation fracturing over slavery, westward expansion, and competing visions of federal power. Kansas was literally bleeding from pro- and anti-slavery violence that year, making Robinson's election a flashpoint. The liquor law debate reflects deeper tensions: can government restrict individual liberty for the "greater good," or does that power inevitably crush freedom? These weren't abstract questions—they foreshadowed the Civil War itself, just five years away. The paper's fierce Democratic defense of the Kansas-Nebraska Act (which allowed territories to decide slavery locally) and its warnings about the Union's dissolution show how completely this election year was consumed by the question: who decides what Americans can do with their own bodies and their own land?
Hidden Gems
- The paper costs two dollars per year, invariably paid in advance—roughly $65 in today's money. The 'invariably in advance' language suggests Indiana newspapers had serious collection problems, possibly tied to the currency chaos mentioned later in the issue.
- A servant girl scandal barely averted prosecution for bigamy by swearing in a church that she'd never been legally married to her seducer, despite having lived with him as his wife and taken his name in society—revealing how fragile women's legal protections were in the 1850s.
- The 'Currency Question' section reveals that Cincinnati banks are deliberately refusing to accept Indiana Free Bank notes unless at a discount, deliberately strangling Indiana's economy. The paper calls this 'systematic robbery' by 'unprincipled and godless' Cincinnati merchants.
- Joseph T. Williams was executed for murdering his father in Roxborough, South Carolina, and protested his innocence from the gallows itself—a grim reminder that the death penalty was public spectacle, with crowds gathering to witness condemned men launched 'into eternity.'
- The paper advertises a Temperance Address signed by seven prominent Indiana reformers, yet devotes its front page to *refuting* prohibitory liquor laws—showing how bitterly divided even reformers were on how to handle drinking.
Fun Facts
- Charles Robinson, whom Senator Jones condemns as a desperado and land-conflict leader in California, would actually become the first Free State Governor of Kansas and a founder of Lawrence—he survived the violence he allegedly led and became a respectable figure, despite this newspaper's character assassination.
- The Maine prohibitory liquor law mentioned here was the nation's first—passed in 1851—and this 1856 legal challenge foreshadows the failure of prohibition as policy: Maine itself would repeal the law within a decade, decades before the 1920s Prohibition era.
- The paper's defense of 'natural rights' to drink connects directly to broader 1856 arguments: if government can prohibit liquor, what stops it from prohibiting other personal choices? This libertarian framing would echo through American law for the next 160+ years.
- The servant girl scandal reflects the complete legal erasure of women: she had no recourse, no grounds to sue, and actually had to commit perjury to protect herself—women wouldn't gain meaningful property rights in Indiana until the 1880s.
- The Indiana Free Banking system referenced in the currency crisis was notoriously unstable; over half of Indiana's free banks would fail during the financial panic of 1857—just months after this paper boasted of their legitimacy.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free