“March 1856: When Indiana Fought Over Immigration, Slavery, and Yellow Fever—and the Union Began to Crack”
What's on the Front Page
The Weekly Indiana State Sentinel's March 13, 1856 front page captures America at a fever pitch of sectional crisis. The lead story reports on a Southern Commercial Convention recently held in Richmond, Virginia, where delegates passed resolutions urging the South to abandon Northern manufactures and patronize only Southern goods and institutions—a dramatic call for economic separation that reflects deepening North-South antagonism over slavery. Simultaneously, the paper covers heated local elections in Greencastle, Indiana, where the anti-immigration "Know Nothing" party suffered stunning defeats at the hands of the "Sharp's Rifle Company"—a pro-slavery militia group—backed by what the paper calls the "Old Line" Democrats. The results suggest the Know Nothings' power is crumbling. Meanwhile, diplomatic tensions simmer: a lengthy dispatch from Washington details a messy exchange between British Minister Crampton and Secretary of State Marcy over Central American territorial disputes, with Lord Clarendon's vague offer to arbitrate causing more confusion than clarity. A grimmer story describes yellow fever ravaging Haiti, with ship crews losing half their men and profiteering undertakers showing more interest in funerals than cures.
Why It Matters
This page captures March 1856—just seven months before the presidential election that would fracture the Democratic Party and elevate Abraham Lincoln. The Southern Commercial Convention represents the growing "fire-eater" movement pushing for economic and political independence from the North, a precursor to secession. The Know Nothing party's collapse in Greencastle foreshadows the party's national disintegration; by 1856, the anti-Catholic, anti-immigrant movement was already being cannibalized by the slavery question. Most importantly, the violent imagery—"Sharp's Rifle Company" armed militias in Indiana—hints at the paramilitary violence that would soon explode in "Bleeding Kansas" and ultimately civil war. The paper's language reveals the era's obsession: Northern "fanatics" versus Southern "institutions," with no middle ground visible.
Hidden Gems
- The paper mentions a new post office established 'on the line of the Wabash Valley Railroad, between Defiance and Napoleon' called 'Colton'—named as a compliment to L.C. Colton, 'late Vice President of the road.' A railroad executive honored by having a town named after him; today that would be unthinkable.
- A Cincinnati horse market report shows 180 horses sold in one week, with prices ranging from $3 to $200, averaging $100-$110—and the purchasers were explicitly 'for the Southern and Eastern markets.' This casual detail reveals how integral the slave economy was to Northern commerce and transportation.
- The Wabash Valley Railroad report notes regular trains 'commenced running yesterday from Toledo to Peru,' with completion to Lafayette expected by May 1856. This railroad expansion was happening in real-time, reshaping the Midwest just as national politics were coming unglued.
- A cautionary tale: Mrs. Matthew Putnam of North Danvers died after her family mistakenly brewed tea from Stramonium (Jimson weed) thinking it was black tea. The paper's editorial aside—'we think that what the Yankees call Apple of Peru, is called, in the West, Jimson weed'—reveals deep regional differences even in folk botany.
Fun Facts
- The paper refers to the Know Nothing party's 'Dark Lantern clan'—a reference to their secretive organizing methods. By 1856, the Know Nothings were America's fastest-growing party, yet they would essentially vanish within two years as slavery consumed all other political divides.
- The Sentinel's editors mock the 'Fusion' strategy of combining Know Nothings with Republicans, sarcastically noting they'll 'have a good time of it in 1856'—they wouldn't. The 1856 presidential election saw Frémont's Republicans, Buchanan's Democrats, and Fillmore's Know Nothings split the vote so badly that Buchanan won with only 45% of the popular vote, a harbinger of the party chaos to come.
- The diplomatic cable from Washington mentions Secretary of State William Marcy and Minister James Buchanan (who would be elected president that November). This March 1856 dispatch captures Buchanan in his final weeks as Minister to Britain, before he'd return home to lead a nation careening toward civil war.
- The paper's contempt for 'Abolitionists' and 'Black Republicans' is matched only by its scorn for Know Nothings—there was no 'safe' political faction in 1856. Every party was fracturing from within over slavery, making this the most unstable election cycle in American history until the 1860s.
- The yellow fever description from Haiti—crews losing 'nearly half their crews,' undertakers profiting from death over recovery—presages the medical horrors of the Civil War itself, just five years away.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free