“Inside Congress on Lincoln's Birthday, 1856: Cantankerous Senators, Rejected Naval Officers, and Why Nobody Can Keep Soldiers Happy”
What's on the Front Page
Congress is consumed by petitions and procedural business on this February morning in 1856, with Senator Stephen Douglas of Illinois resuming his seat after an absence. The Senate spends the session reviewing dozens of memorials—requests from military widows seeking pensions, naval officers demanding restoration after dismissal by a controversial naval board, and various citizens seeking compensation for past services. The most heated discussion centers on a resolution from Senator Thompson of Kentucky proposing to abolish the Western Military Asylum at Harrodsburg, citing its $500,000 annual expense and the soldiers' melancholy disposition. Thompson notes with pointed sarcasm that the old veterans "went moping about" in Kentucky, pining for "salt water" and unable to procure their preferred spirits—Schiedam schnapps or Irish whiskey. Meanwhile, the House engages in its fourth voting round to elect a public printer, with Follett of Ohio leading with 84 votes, Wendell of New York trailing with 66, and Farnham of Washington holding 19.
Why It Matters
This snapshot captures Congress in early 1856, just months before the presidential election that would bring James Buchanan to power and accelerate the nation toward civil war. The endless parade of Revolutionary War pension claims and military compensation disputes reflects a nation still settling accounts from its founding era, while the heated debate over the Harrodsburg asylum reveals deep sectional tensions. More tellingly, the prominence of the naval board controversy—with multiple senators defending dismissed officers—hints at the institutional turmoil brewing beneath the surface. The casual cruelty in Thompson's comments about soldiers' homesickness exposes the era's indifference to veterans' welfare, a contrast to the elaborate process of petitioning Congress for relief.
Hidden Gems
- Senator Thompson's vicious mockery of the Harrodsburg asylum residents reveals shocking mid-19th-century attitudes: he suggests it would be cheaper to board old soldiers at 'first-class hotels' than maintain a military facility, and complains they're miserable because they can't access their preferred liquor—treating military service compensation as almost comedic.
- The naval board controversy permeates this entire session, with at least seven separate petitions from officers (or their representatives) seeking restoration to positions they lost. This suggests a major institutional purge happening in the Navy during 1856, yet it barely registers as a crisis in the press.
- Commodore Charles Stewart, a famous naval hero, was placed on the 'reserved list' (effectively fired) by the naval board, prompting the New Jersey legislature to pass formal resolutions condemning the action—an extraordinary measure showing how controversial these dismissals had become.
- The subscription rates reveal the newspaper's economics: the Daily Union cost $10/year, the Semi-Weekly was $3/year, and the Weekly just $1/year—meaning a working person might afford only the weekly edition, while the elite subscribed to daily delivery.
- Multiple senators introduced bills for incredibly specific infrastructure projects: Van Buren, Arkansas needed a jail; Boston needed a courthouse-post office combination; the Des Moines and Rock River rapids required improvement. Congress micromanaged American development down to the township level.
Fun Facts
- Stephen Douglas, the senator whose return is noted at the session's opening, would become Lincoln's 1860 presidential rival—the 'Little Giant' whose Kansas-Nebraska Act had inflamed sectional tensions. He was politically dominant in February 1856 but would be overshadowed by events within four years.
- The endless naval board dismissals mentioned throughout this page reflect a real 1855-1856 scandal: Secretary of the Navy James C. Dobbin implemented controversial officer reductions, infuriating the naval establishment and prompting congressional backlash that lasted for years. It's one of the era's quieter institutional crises.
- The Harrodsburg Springs referenced in Thompson's snide remarks were indeed once a celebrated American resort—now its glamour had apparently faded so completely that housing military pensioners seemed insulting to both the facility and the town.
- The subscription system described—with club rates for five copies of the Daily at $40—shows how newspapers built circulation: institutions, political parties, and wealthy subscribers would buy in bulk and distribute them, functioning as an early form of media circulation infrastructure.
- This 34th Congress, First Session, convened in March 1855 and would grapple with the Kansas-Nebraska fallout for months. By February 1856, sectional tensions were mounting but Congress still operated through courtesy and procedure—by the next Congress, physical violence would erupt on the chamber floor.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free