“Benjamin Franklin's Radical 1753 Letter on Faith (Republished 1856): Why Good Deeds Beat Prayers”
What's on the Front Page
The New York Dispatch's January 6, 1856 front page is dominated by a reader Q&A column answering questions on everything from English law to theology. The most striking item is a lengthy 1753 letter from Benjamin Franklin to a friend, republished here to defend Franklin against accusations of infidelity. In the letter, Franklin articulates a remarkably progressive faith: he argues that true religion consists of "real good works; works of kindness, charity, mercy and public spirit," not empty ceremonialism. He dismisses showy prayers and church rituals as performative, preferring the parable of the Good Samaritan as his moral exemplar. The paper also addresses a question about Universalist doctrine, explaining that sect's belief that Christ's redemption extends to all humanity, and that eternal punishment cannot exist because God's perfections demand mercy. Meanwhile, a separate response provides detailed U.S. Patent Office statistics from 1841-1854, showing explosive growth in American innovation—3,324 patent applications filed in 1854 alone, nearly double the 1853 figure.
Why It Matters
In 1856, America was fracturing over slavery and sectarian theology. This page captures the intellectual ferment of the moment: religious progressives were openly questioning Calvinist orthodoxy and literal damnation, while simultaneously the nation's mechanical ingenuity was accelerating toward industrial dominance. The republication of Franklin's letter—arguing for private conscience over institutional religious authority—signals the Enlightenment values many educated Americans were defending against both conservative churches and political extremism. Patent growth statistics underscore that while the nation tore itself apart politically, American inventors were outpacing Britain in practical innovation, laying groundwork for post-Civil War industrial supremacy.
Hidden Gems
- The subscription price reveals stark economic inequality: city readers paid 4 cents per copy, but country newsvendors charged 4-6 cents depending on delivery distance—a premium that meant rural Americans paid more for the same information, a friction that would persist for decades.
- Dr. Franklin's theology is explicitly anti-hierarchical: he directly attacks "those bigots who presume to take the consciences of others into their keeping," language that echoes the democratic rhetoric of 1776 and suggests religious authority was seen as tyrannical by intellectual elites.
- The paper's advertising rates are granular and revealing: regular ads cost 10 cents per line first insertion, then 5 cents; but 'Notices in Reading Columns' cost 25 cents per line—indicating that editorial content placement was for sale to the wealthy.
- Patent statistics show the trajectory: in 1841, 495 patents were issued; by 1854, that jumped to 902—an 82% increase in just 13 years, capturing the velocity of American technological transformation on the eve of the Civil War.
- The paper's response on divorce law notes that 'Adultery is the only cause recognised in our statute books as sufficient to command absolute divorce,' revealing how restrictive marriage law was—women had virtually no exit, a legal reality that would frustrate reformers for another 70+ years.
Fun Facts
- Benjamin Franklin's 1753 letter, republished here 100 years later, was making an argument that would've seemed radical: that good deeds matter more than doctrinal purity. This 'works over faith' theology directly contradicted Calvinist America and foreshadowed the Social Gospel movement that would dominate mainline Protestantism by the 1890s.
- The U.S. Patent Office statistics on this page show American patents outpacing Britain by a claimed 4:3 ratio in 1855. By 1900, the U.S. would hold more patents than Britain, France, and Germany combined—the statistical moment captured here was the inflection point of American technological dominance.
- The Dispatch's editors reference 'Tazewell county, Illinois' and 'Cave in the Rock'—both locations on the frontier that by 1856 were becoming settled territory. Cave in the Rock, mentioned as an outlaw hideout anecdote setting, would become a historic landmark; Tazewell would boom with railroad expansion after the Civil War.
- The paper's discussion of Universalism—that all souls will eventually be reconciled to God—was heretical by 1856 standards but growing among educated Americans. By 1900, Universalism had become mainstream enough that it merged with Unitarianism, showing how rapidly American theology secularized.
- Dr. Franklin's casual invocation of the "cold bath" as health treatment connects to 19th-century hydropathic medicine, a genuine fad among the educated elite. Water cure resorts became fashionable tourist destinations by the 1870s, making Franklin's casual mention prescient of coming wellness obsessions.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free