Thursday
January 3, 1856
Weekly Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis [Ind.]) — Indiana, Marion
“When Republicans Called Each Other Traitors: Inside the Party's 1856 Civil War”
Art Deco mural for January 3, 1856
Original newspaper scan from January 3, 1856
Original front page — Weekly Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis [Ind.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Indiana State Sentinel, a Democratic Party organ, leads with scathing coverage of the anti-slavery Republican coalition fracturing before the 1856 election. Representative John Dunn of Indiana delivered a withering floor speech exposing Republican hypocrisy—he read back their own newspapers' vicious attacks on Nathaniel Banks from 1854, when the Tribune and Times called him a "traitor" and "betrayer of the North" for voting to advance the Kansas-Nebraska debate. Now those same editors championed Banks for Speaker. The paper also reports on ambitious railroad consolidation efforts, with delegates from Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, and Iowa meeting at Fort Wayne to forge a transcontinental American Central Railway stretching from the Atlantic to Council Bluffs, Iowa. Locally, Evansville suffered a devastating courthouse fire on New Year's Day that destroyed valuable woodwork and county records, with damages estimated between $30,000 and $50,000. The page also chronicles anti-German mob violence in New Albany on Christmas Eve, where rowdies attacked a German theater and subsequently terrorized German-owned businesses.

Why It Matters

This moment captures American politics at a critical hinge. The 1856 election would be the first contested by the brand-new Republican Party, and this page shows the chaos of realignment—Free Soilers, Know Nothings, and anti-slavery coalitionists scrambling for power. The railroad reports illustrate the era's obsession with connecting America's interior to coastal markets—infrastructure that would literally bind the nation together even as slavery threatened to tear it apart. The anti-German violence reflects the Know Nothing Party's xenophobic appeals, which influenced mainstream Republican strategy in the North even as slavery consumed national debate.

Hidden Gems
  • A boy between 4 and 5 years old was beaten to death by his guardian, an unmarried woman named Miss Packhurst in New York, who would torture him for 2-3 hours at a time with a whip or whalebones—a shocking reveal of domestic violence in an era when such abuse often went unchecked.
  • An express company dispute on the New York Central Railroad shows competing firms—the People's Express Company and the American Express Company—fighting over who could conduct business on the cars, prefiguring monopoly battles that would define the Gilded Age.
  • A firecracker explosion in Columbus, Ohio on Christmas Day destroyed a grocery store when the proprietor casually lit one to test whether it would 'go off'—the blast collapsed walls and caved in the roof, an accidental tragedy capturing how dangerous everyday goods were.
  • The paper mentions Representative Cumback from the 7th district being mocked even by 'boys' in the city and struggling to get the House's attention until fellow Republican Schuyler Colfax (later Vice President) finally acknowledged him with a 'slight chuckle and knowing wink'—suggesting how fragile a newcomer's status was.
  • A letter-to-editor feud between Democratic editor S. A. Hall and Governor Wright discusses litigation over Indiana's new State Bank, revealing intense partisan battles over financial monopolies that presaged the greenback and banking wars of the 1860s-1890s.
Fun Facts
  • Nathaniel Banks, the Republican speaker-elect being defended and attacked in this debate, would become one of the Civil War's most famous Union generals—yet this page shows he was already controversial within his own party two years before Fort Sumter over procedural votes on slavery.
  • The proposed 'American Central Railway' from the Atlantic to Council Bluffs, Iowa was never completed as described, but the fever to build transcontinental railroads exploded after 1856; the Union Pacific, chartered just two years later in 1862, finally made this dream real—and required massive government land grants.
  • Schuyler Colfax, mentioned here as a House member, would become Speaker in 1863 and Vice President under Grant in 1869—this casual mention of him rewarding a junior colleague shows him already wielding influence in Republican circles.
  • The Evansville courthouse fire destroying county records happened in one of Indiana's most important river towns; Evansville's location on the Ohio River made it a crucial point for slavery debate, as enslaved people could escape across the river to free Ohio.
  • The Know Nothing-Republican fusion that dominates this page's analysis would effectively dissolve by 1856—the party's anti-immigrant platform proved incompatible with Republican free-labor ideology, showing how the slavery question swallowed all other political divisions.
Contentious Politics Federal Election Crime Violent Transportation Rail Disaster Fire
January 2, 1856 January 4, 1856

Also on January 3

View all 10 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free