What's on the Front Page
The Indiana State Sentinel's November 28, 1846 edition opens with a lengthy editorial titled 'The True Object of Government,' a searing critique of government overreach that would sound familiar to modern libertarians. Drawing from the Rochester Daily Advertiser, the piece argues that Americans have forgotten government exists merely to protect inherent rights—not to dispense special favors to the wealthy and connected. The editorial uses a vivid hypothetical: imagine a manufacturer petitions for an exclusive right to make bank notes, then uses tariff protection to gouge fellow citizens on cotton fabrics while growing immensely rich at public expense. 'Who grave it the right to compel everybody to buy their cottons?' the writer demands. Beyond this philosophical broadside, the page is dominated by estate administration notices for Daniel Ropen and Nathan Hardin (deceased Marion County residents), public auctions of their personal property scheduled for December, and advertisements for daguerreotype portraits, music boxes, cooking stoves, lottery tickets, and a school opening at the Baptist Church.
Why It Matters
This 1846 snapshot captures America at a pivotal moment: the Mexican-American War had just ended (Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo signed in February 1848, just ahead), westward expansion was accelerating, and the nation was deeply divided over tariffs and federal power. The editorial's anger at protective tariffs reflects the real schism between industrial North and agricultural South—a tension that would explode into civil war fifteen years later. The complaint about government using its authority to benefit special interests over the common good was a core Jacksonian-era debate. Indianapolis, as Indiana's capital since 1821, was a growing hub of this democratic conversation, making this local paper a genuine window into how ordinary Americans thought about power and fairness.
Hidden Gems
- The daguerreotype portrait shop advertised by the subscriber in Norris's Building (corner of Washington and Meridian streets) represents cutting-edge 1840s technology—yet the ad emphasizes that portraits are 'perfectly satisfactory in every respect,' suggesting customers were still skeptical about this new-fangled art. Daguerreotypes, invented in 1839, were so novel that reassurance was necessary.
- The auction of Nathan Hardin's estate offered 'Ten months' credit' for purchases over three dollars, but 'Three dollars and the price of the fat hog, must be cash in hand'—a fascinating glimpse into how rural Indiana commerce worked: credit was extended on larger purchases, but livestock sales were strictly pay-as-you-go, likely because pigs were portable and could be moved before payment cleared.
- Three separate Alexandria Lottery advertisements (Classes Q, R, and B for 1846) tout prizes ranging from $10,000 to split pots, with certificates of packages sold to speculators—this was legal gambling run by legitimate lottery operators, and lotteries were a major source of state revenue before income taxes.
- The postage rate table reveals the incredible cost of mail in 1846: letters under 300 miles cost 5 cents (worth about $1.75 today), and the note 'Postage must be paid' appears in the masthead, meaning senders bore the cost, not recipients—this would change later in the century.
- C. H. Keith's school advertisement, opening December 7th at the Baptist Church, charged only $3 for reading and spelling, $4 for writing/arithmetic/geography, and $5 for algebra/philosophy/astronomy—yet explicitly noted the school was 'kept in a church' but would permit 'no sectarian bias'—a delicate 1840s negotiation of religion and public education.
Fun Facts
- The editorial's fury at tariffs directly connects to the so-called 'Tariff of 1828' (Tariff of Abominations) and the 1833 compromise that averted the South Carolina Nullification Crisis. By 1846, this exact argument—that protective tariffs enriched manufacturers at the expense of farmers and consumers—was tearing the nation apart. The Mexican-American War would make it worse: new territories meant new fights over whether they'd be free or slave states.
- Daguerreotypes, advertised here as a marvel, had been commercially available for only seven years. The photographer's shop in Indianapolis was on the absolute frontier of American photography. Within a decade, daguerreotypes would be displaced by wet-plate collodion photos—the technology evolved at bewildering speed.
- The lottery advertisements show that before the Civil War, state-sponsored lotteries were respectable fundraising tools, not moral panics. Indiana, like most states, used them to finance infrastructure. They wouldn't become taboo until the late 1800s, when reformers deemed them corrupt.
- The postage rates published here—5 cents for letters under 300 miles—reflect a system about to change dramatically. The first postage stamps were issued in 1847 (just months after this paper), and the Post Office would shift toward prepaid postage, revolutionizing mail.
- Indianapolis in November 1846 was a young capital city (only 25 years old) with maybe 3,000-4,000 residents, yet it supported a state-official newspaper, daguerreotype studios, schools, estates worth liquidating, and lottery speculators. The city was booming on canal-building and speculation—which makes the editorial's warning about government favoritism especially poignant, as these very corruptions were fueling the city's growth.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free