“War, Tariffs & Cornfields: Why Indians & White Settlers Were Fighting Over Crops in 1846”
What's on the Front Page
The New-York Tribune for August 14, 1846, captures a nation at a critical political crossroads. The lead story from Washington correspondent "Richelieu" reports that the Whig party is gaining substantial ground in North Carolina, with their majority expected to "double or treble" Henry Clay's 1844 result. The cause? Deep unpopularity of President Polk's new tariff policy at the South. Meanwhile, the correspondent reveals that Commodore Conner has been authorized to offer peace terms to Mexico—a significant development in the Mexican-American War that had begun just weeks earlier. The article notes that this diplomatic initiative was suggested long ago by the administration, and that a recent communication from U.S. Consul Brack at Mexico likely prompted renewed action. Notably, most members of Congress have fled Washington for the summer, leaving the capital "quite deserted," though the business of war continues behind the scenes.
Why It Matters
August 1846 was a pivotal moment in American history. The Mexican-American War had begun in May, and it immediately became a lightning rod for political division. Northern Whigs and abolitionists opposed the conflict as a Southern expansion scheme, while Democrats largely backed Polk's ambitions. The tariff dispute mentioned here was equally toxic—the Walker Tariff of 1846 had just lowered protective duties, benefiting the South but outraging Northern manufacturers. These conflicts would intensify over the next two years, ultimately forcing the question of slavery's expansion into conquered Mexican territory—a crisis that would lead directly to the Compromise of 1850 and, ultimately, to the Civil War. This newspaper captures that moment when the fractures were becoming irreparable.
Hidden Gems
- A job posting seeks "active young Men" to travel South and West as book agents, promising $50 signing bonus plus $10/year salary—with the tantalizing claim that industrious agents could 'make over $500, clear of all expense.' This was wildly optimistic sales pitch territory, suggesting the 1840s book business was already built on aggressive recruitment and ambitious commission structures.
- The Tonawanda Indians dispute reveals a visceral conflict: Native Americans and white settlers literally harvested from the same cornfield, with Indians arrested for assault and battery when they fought back. The writer notes the Indians 'stand indicted before the County Court,' exposing how the legal system weaponized against indigenous people fighting for treaty-promised lands.
- Subscription rates show the Tribune cost just $5 per year—or 12.5 cents per week for daily delivery. The weekly edition cost $2 per annum with bulk discounts (20 copies for $24), suggesting Horace Greeley's famous 'go West, young man' paper was explicitly designed as affordable mass media.
- A wool merchant's letter from Springfield, Massachusetts reports selling Ohio-grown wool at 69 cents per pound, with a warning: prices depend on whether 'the new Tan bill does not become a law.' The tariff battle was so immediate and real that commodity prices fluctuated based on pending legislation.
- The paper advertises 'The Treasury of History' by Daniel Adee as a new reference work, with the Tribune's book critic explicitly warning readers NOT to rely on summaries alone, insisting that 'the finest philosophic history of events is far less valuable than those which impart to us directly the spirit that animated those events.' Educational philosophy was being actively debated in the press.
Fun Facts
- The correspondent mentions a 'Court of Inquiry on Gen. Gaines' in progress at Old Point Comfort, Virginia—this was the court martial of General Edmund Pendleton Gaines, a War of 1812 hero who had been censured for alleged insubordination during the Mexican-American War. His case became a flashpoint in debates about military authority that would echo through the Civil War.
- The Tribune mentions Commodore Conner authorized to negotiate peace with Mexico. This was David Porter's superior—Porter himself would later become superintendent of the Naval Academy and help modernize the U.S. Navy. These wartime decisions made careers.
- The Tonawanda Indian letter references the Treaty of 1842, which stipulated Indians leave by April 1st—but the author notes the President refused to execute it and referred the case to the Senate. This was Andrew Jackson's successor William Henry Harrison's party (Whigs) still fighting Jackson's Indian Removal Act legacy, even as Polk (Democrat) was expanding westward through war.
- Horace Greeley's byline 'BY GREELEY McELRATH' appears on the masthead—McElrath was his partner. Just four years later, Greeley would run his own printing establishment and become one of America's most influential editors, eventually running for president in 1872.
- The paper advertises Dunlap's 'Small Books on Great Subjects' series—compact enough to fit in a pocket. This was the era when serialized knowledge and affordable print were democratizing information, just as the telegraph was beginning to revolutionize news transmission itself.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free