What's on the Front Page
The Somerset Herald leads with Senator Daniel Webster's sweeping speech on war financing, delivered as Congress grapples with the Mexican-American War's mounting costs. Webster warns that the government faces a $20 million deficit by July 1847 and castigates the Executive's revenue proposals as "conjectural, uncertain, and not fit to be the basis of provisions." He systematically dismantles Treasury Secretary suggestions to tax tea and coffee, expand warehouse systems, and sell public lands cheaper—calling these mere "opinions" without solid foundation. Instead, Webster insists Congress must impose "substantial taxation" or accept a public debt, noting that military expenses have already reached half a million dollars *per day*. He punctures the government's optimism about loan prospects, warning that wealthy capitalists won't consent to specie being "locked up" under the proposed Subtreasury system. The speech crescendos with Webster demanding the people deserve to know the war's ultimate objectives—a pointed challenge to President Polk's administration. The paper also runs a charming cautionary tale in verse about a struggling farmer named Sniggle, whose prosperous neighbor Blowse reveals the secret to success: "I ALWAYS TAKE MY COUNTY PAPER."
Why It Matters
This July 1846 edition captures America at a critical juncture. The Mexican-American War, which began just two months earlier, was exploding the federal budget and fracturing the nation along sectional lines. Webster, a Massachusetts Whig and nationalist, embodied growing skepticism about Polk's war and its true aims—many northerners suspected it was a slave power plot to expand slavery into conquered territories. The revenue debate wasn't academic; it forced Americans to confront whether they'd pay for territorial expansion through taxation or debt. The war ultimately cost the U.S. roughly $100 million and killed 13,000 soldiers, while adding 525,000 square miles to the nation—territory that would ignite the slavery crisis leading directly to the Civil War fifteen years later.
Hidden Gems
- The Somerset Herald subscription cost was $2 per year, payable half-yearly in advance—but subscribers faced a penalty of $1.50 if they failed to pay within the year, making the actual cost $3.50 for delinquents (roughly equivalent to $85-100 today).
- Webster casually mentions that mounted volunteer regiments cost the government three times as much as infantry units of equal size—a detail buried in his analysis that reveals the stunning expense of the Mexican campaign, where horses had to be shipped vast distances across hostile terrain.
- The farmer's tale appearing on the front page wasn't entertainment filler; it's a direct advertisement for newspaper subscriptions disguised as moral instruction, suggesting that county papers were seen as essential business and farming guides, not mere gossip sheets.
- Webster references a War Department document from when Joel Poinsett was Secretary of War to support his cost estimates—showing how legislators mined archival precedents to argue contemporary policy, even from Democrat administrations.
- The phrase "New Series" and "Vol. 4, No. 35" indicate this is a relatively young publication reinventing itself, suggesting the Somerset Herald was struggling to build readership in rural Pennsylvania.
Fun Facts
- Webster's prediction proved prescient: the Mexican-American War did force the government to choose between taxation and debt, ultimately spurring the Tariff of 1846 and Treasury notes—exactly what he warned would undermine the Subtreasury system he opposed. The war debt haunted federal finances for decades.
- Webster's skepticism about tea and coffee taxes reflects a deep American sensitivity: the Boston Tea Party was still living memory in 1846 (just 73 years prior), and any tax on imported goods triggered revolutionary-era anxieties about parliamentary overreach.
- The farmer Sniggle's plight—working constantly yet unable to make ends meet—mirrors the actual rural crisis of 1846 Pennsylvania, where agricultural prices had collapsed from overproduction, making the county paper's practical advice genuinely valuable to survival.
- Webster spent considerable ink attacking ad valorem (percentage-based) duties in favor of specific (per-pound) taxes, a technical distinction that dominated 19th-century tariff debates and revealed how much congressional arguments hinged on obscure customs mechanics.
- This speech marks Webster near the end of his political influence: he'd be dead within four years (1852), unable to witness how the war he criticized would reshape America and accelerate the sectional crisis that destroyed the Whig Party he represented.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free