Sunday
June 7, 1846
Sunday dispatch (New York [N.Y.]) — New York City, New York
“A Doctor Calls Gout a Hoax, Plus a Shipwreck Curse (1846)”
Art Deco mural for June 7, 1846
Original newspaper scan from June 7, 1846
Original front page — Sunday dispatch (New York [N.Y.]) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Sunday Dispatch, a three-cent weekly published at 41 Ann Street by Williamson Burns, leads with an extended medical treatise by Dr. Dickson debunking the fashionable disease of gout. The doctor argues that "gout" is little more than "hypothetical gibberish" invented by physicians who don't understand it—a term lazy doctors use to sound learned while actually curing nothing. He dismisses the aristocratic pretension surrounding the ailment, mocking how "mushroom squires" and "retired shop-keepers" eagerly embrace the diagnosis as a status symbol. Dickson insists gout is simply periodic inflammation with chalky deposits, no different in principle from other inflammatory diseases, and should be treated like ague with temperature management and certain medicines. The page also runs the opening chapters of "The Prophetess," a serialized Gothic tale of Irish smugglers and maritime murder, featuring a mysterious shipwreck and a prophecy of vengeance unfolding on the stormy coast of Wicklow.

Why It Matters

In 1846, America was experiencing rapid expansion and social anxiety about who belonged to the upper classes. The gout article reflects genuine medical confusion and the emerging professional status-consciousness of doctors in American cities. Gout had long been called "the disease of kings," so its diagnosis became a peculiar form of social currency—proof of affluence and leisure. Dickson's skepticism represents a growing movement toward rational medicine and against the vague nomenclature that had dominated practice for centuries. Meanwhile, the serialized fiction reflects the Irish immigration crisis unfolding in real time: 1846 was the first year of the Great Famine, and Irish stories were becoming increasingly central to American newspaper content as desperate immigrants flooded ports like New York.

Hidden Gems
  • The newspaper explicitly charges "THREE CENTS PER WEEK TO CITY SUBSCRIBERS, Or One Dollar a Year in Advance by Mail"—meaning yearly mail subscriptions cost $1, equivalent to roughly $33 today, making national newspaper distribution a significant financial commitment for rural readers.
  • Dr. Dickson invokes the authority of "Darwin" and "Sydenham" and even "Dr. Samuel Johnson's explanation in his dictionary" to argue gout behaves like ague—showing how 19th-century physicians built arguments through historical authority rather than experimentation, a practice Dickson himself is challenging.
  • The Gothic serial features smugglers running "a capital run of brandy and lace" through Irish coastal caves—lace smuggling was a genuine and widespread enterprise along European coasts during this period, embedded here as casual period detail.
  • The captain character is named "Gallaher" and bears a "cut across his right eye and cheek"—detailed physical marks that would have helped readers recognize recurring characters across weekly installments in an era before consistent character illustrations in newspapers.
  • The advertisement rate is "One Dollar per Square (of sixteen lines) the first insertion, and Fifty Cents for every subsequent insertion"—meaning repeat advertisers got a 50% discount, an early form of bulk-rate incentive pricing.
Fun Facts
  • Dr. Dickson cites the poet Crabbe, who "studied physic, but left the profession in early life to take orders"—George Crabbe (1754-1832) was a real English clergyman-poet who had indeed briefly practiced medicine before switching careers, and his medical satire in *The Village* was genuinely influential in medical reform circles.
  • The article references "Dr. Holland, Physician Extraordinary to the Queen"—this was likely Sir Henry Holland (1788-1873), who was actually Queen Victoria's physician at precisely this moment, giving Dickson's dismissal of royal medical authority a pointed contemporary sting.
  • The serialized tale takes place on the "coast of Wicklow" in Ireland during a December storm—1846 was the exact moment Ireland's potato famine was beginning to devastate coastal communities like those around Wicklow, making this Gothic fiction eerily prophetic of actual horrors unfolding in real time.
  • The woman in the hovel mentions "the prophecy" as a supernatural curse—but prophecies in Irish folklore and Catholic tradition were genuinely believed to carry power, reflecting how immigrant readers brought Old World superstitions to New York newspapers.
  • This is *Volume I, Number 27*—meaning the Sunday Dispatch was only six months old when this issue ran, making it an early entrant in the competitive mass-market newspaper boom that would transform American media by mid-century.
Anxious Gilded Age Science Medicine Immigration Disaster Maritime Arts Culture
June 6, 1846 June 8, 1846

Also on June 7

1856
1856: When Delaware Ran Four Lotteries at Once—and the Mail Route to Utah Cost...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
Stephen Douglas's Last Stand: The Speech That Couldn't Save the Union...
The Bedford gazette (Bedford, Pa.)
1862
How a Scottish Gamekeeper Became Japan's Interpreter to Napoleon III—Plus Civil...
The Placer herald (Auburn, Placer County, Calif.)
1863
1863: When Mobs Threatened Newspapers & Democrats Debated Losing the Union |...
Chicago daily tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1864
A Maine Minister's Fiery Rebuttal to Canadian Doubters—June 1864
The Portland daily press (Portland, Me.)
1865
June 1865: Presidential order rebuilds the Union while explosion kills 200 in...
The south-western (Shreveport, La.)
1866
Johnson Issues War Warning: Irish-American Fenians Massing on Canadian...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
Congressman Blaine Takes the Floor in His Own Defense—And It Gets Heated Fast...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
When Oleomargarine Split the Senate: Inside 1886 Washington's Strangest Debates
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
A Bicycle-Obsessed British Minister, Missing Royal Corpses, and the Sudan...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1906
1906: A suspicious death in Omaha, political rallies, and why everyone wanted...
The Loup City northwestern (Loup City, Neb.)
1926
When Congress Got Physical: The 1926 Inkwell Incident That Made Headlines
The Elkins inter-mountain (Elkins, W. Va.)
1927
A New York Pastor's Homecoming Sermon & the Lost Art of Declamation (Newberry,...
The herald and news (Newberry S.C.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free