“A Senator's Fury Over Fake News (1846): When Congress Battled Over Western Roads—and the Press Got It Wrong”
What's on the Front Page
Senator William Woodbridge of Michigan takes to the pages of The Daily Union to correct what he calls a deeply flawed newspaper account of his Senate remarks on a crucial internal improvements bill. The bill in question would grant public lands to Michigan for completing railroads and canals across the peninsula—infrastructure projects Woodbridge argues are vital to his state's future. His letter, published alongside his full prepared remarks, reveals the sharp partisan nature of congressional reporting in 1846. Woodbridge is particularly incensed that the paper misrepresented his argument about the "utter helplessness" of newer states, which lack the power to tax property within their borders that original states possessed. His sprawling rebuttal occupies nearly the entire front page, detailing how these transportation routes would unlock Michigan's potential by connecting Detroit—long isolated from the American interior by impassable swamps and wilderness—to Ohio's growing population and resources. He invokes the ghost of Jefferson's vision and recalls the blood spilled fifty years earlier to wrest the territory from Britain and Native Americans.
Why It Matters
This 1846 dispute sits at the heart of antebellum America's great struggle over federal power and western development. The Mexican-American War would begin in weeks, but Congress was already locked in debate over how to bind the sprawling Union together—and whether the federal government should bankroll internal improvements. The controversy over land grants for canals and railroads would define politics for decades, pitting those who saw federal investment as essential nation-building against strict constructionists who viewed it as unconstitutional overreach. Michigan, admitted to the Union only in 1837, embodied the anxieties of new western states seeking parity with older coastal powers. Woodbridge's invocation of Jefferson and the Northwest Territory showed how that era's politicians grappled with their revolutionary inheritance while confronting a rapidly expanding nation.
Hidden Gems
- The paper explicitly states it will be published 'twice weekly during the sitting of Congress, and semi-weekly if during the recess'—revealing how legislative calendars literally determined newspaper publication schedules in 1846.
- Woodbridge notes that this bill 'has been pending here in 1842; that it passed the Senate during that session'—meaning Congress could let major bills languish for years without final passage, a far slower legislative process than modern readers might imagine.
- The senator casually mentions that 'three-fourths of those lots which border on the road have become already sold' based merely on the *probability* the bill would pass—showing land speculation was so rampant that proposed federal projects could move markets before becoming law.
- Woodbridge reveals Jefferson personally negotiated with Native American tribes in 1808-9 to acquire 'a right of way for the permanent road' plus 'a large tract of land to each side of it'—a striking admission that westward infrastructure was explicitly built on Indian dispossession.
- The admission rates are brutally specific: 'To slay lines, or less, three insertions $1.00; Every additional insertion 25 cents'—meaning even small-town editors could afford to run notices repeatedly, enabling the kind of lengthy congressional corrections that fill this page.
Fun Facts
- Woodbridge notes that 'it will be precisely fifty years on the 4th day of July next, when, for the first time, your banner of stars and stripes was unfurled over the ramparts of the old fort at Detroit'—meaning this front page was published mere weeks before Michigan would celebrate its golden jubilee of American occupation on July 4, 1846, a milestone that would have been freshly significant to readers.
- The senator invokes the British Treaty of 1794 and General Wayne's decisive victories over 'the powerful Indian tribes of the old northwestern territory'—yet by 1846, most of those tribes had been removed or confined to reservations, making his triumphalist history a form of retroactive justification for ethnic cleansing happening in real time.
- Woodbridge claims that even 37 years prior (around 1809), Ohio's settlement had barely progressed north of Delaware or west from Cleveland—yet by 1846, Ohio was already a powerhouse state with major cities, showing the explosive speed of American westward expansion in just one generation.
- The paper's masthead credits 'Thomas Ritchie' as editor—Ritchie was one of the most influential Democratic editors in America and would wield enormous power over party politics through this very newspaper for decades to come.
- This front page is essentially a lengthy op-ed from a sitting U.S. Senator correcting press coverage—a practice that speaks to how fluid the line between news and partisan advocacy was in 1846, with senators routinely using newspapers as personal political platforms.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free