What's on the Front Page
The Somerset Herald's front page is dominated by a detailed account of the Whig State Convention held in Harrisburg on March 11, 1846, where delegates from across Pennsylvania gathered to nominate a candidate for Canal Commissioner. After three rounds of balloting, James M. Power of Dauphin County emerged victorious, securing 58 votes on the third ballot to defeat fellow candidates Samuel D. Karns (44 votes) and Joseph Konigmacher (6 votes). The convention, presided over by George Darsie of Allegheny County, featured elaborate parliamentary procedures with senatorial and representative delegates from all 28 of Pennsylvania's districts carefully listed by name. Perhaps more compelling than the nomination itself were the fiery resolutions adopted by the convention, which unleashed a fierce attack on the Democratic administration's free-trade policies and President James K. Polk's efforts to dismantle the protective Tariff of 1842—the Whigs' signature achievement.
Why It Matters
In 1846, American politics was consumed by the tariff question. The Tariff of 1842, passed by a Whig Congress under President William Henry Harrison, had become the central symbol of opposing economic philosophies. Polk's Democratic administration was actively pushing for tariff reduction toward free trade, which threatened Pennsylvania's booming iron, coal, and textile industries. For a manufacturing-heavy state like Pennsylvania, protection from foreign competition wasn't an abstract economic theory—it meant jobs, wages, and survival for entire communities. This convention represents the Whig Party's desperate fight to preserve protectionism before the incoming Walker Tariff of 1846 would slash rates dramatically. The party's careful staging of this event and its inflammatory resolutions reveal how high the stakes had become in pre-Civil War America.
Hidden Gems
- The newspaper itself cost TWO DOLLARS PER ANNUM paid half-yearly in advance—but if you didn't pay within the year, you'd owe $3.60, a 80% penalty. That's a surprisingly aggressive collection practice for a rural Pennsylvania paper in the 1840s.
- J.R. Edie of Somerset (listed as a delegate) would have been reading about his own convention participation in his local paper—this same Somerset Herald. Talk about local political celebrity.
- The convention appointed a State Central Committee of 15 members, and one member, John P. Sanderson of Lebanon, is listed first—suggesting he held seniority or special status in the party structure, though the paper offers no explanation of why.
- The resolutions accuse the Democratic Party of deceiving Pennsylvania voters in the 'late Presidential contest' (1844), claiming Polk promised protection but delivered free trade. This is political memory at work—the convention is essentially saying 'we told you so' just two years after Polk's election.
- Samuel D. Karns, who lost the nomination, was reportedly authorized to state through Mr. Magehan that he pledged 'hearted support of the nominee' despite his defeat—this announcement 'was received with unbounded applause,' suggesting party unity was carefully choreographed and celebrated for the record.
Fun Facts
- James M. Power, the newly nominated Whig candidate for Canal Commissioner, was being nominated for a position that controlled massive infrastructure spending in Pennsylvania. The canal system was literally the Interstate Highway System of 1846—economically vital but also a source of patronage and corruption that would haunt Pennsylvania politics for decades.
- The convention delegates included Andrew G. Curtin of Centre County, listed here as a young representative delegate. Curtin would go on to become Pennsylvania's Governor during the Civil War (1861-1867) and a towering figure in Republican politics—his presence at this 1846 Whig convention shows the party pipeline that created Civil War-era leadership.
- The resolutions invoke 'the glorious days of 1840,' referring to William Henry Harrison's Whig victory. Harrison died just 31 days into his presidency in 1841, but here in 1846, the Whigs are still mining that brief moment as their party's glory days—a sign of how desperate they'd become.
- The convention's fierce attack on the 'anti-protection and free trade doctrines' of Treasury Secretary James K. Walker would prove prophetic—the Walker Tariff passed just months after this convention (in July 1846), slashing tariff rates and vindicating the Whigs' warnings. Pennsylvania's iron and textile industries would indeed suffer severe disruption.
- The State Central Committee appointed here included Morton McMichael of Philadelphia, who was not just a politician but also a newspaper editor and publisher. This overlapping of media and political power meant that convention delegates could literally control the narrative of events they participated in.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free