“Inside Tyler's Mess: How Washington Forced Bureaucrats to Buy Party Newspapers (1846)”
What's on the Front Page
The Sunday Dispatch serves up a sprawling 1846 political exposé disguised as a letter from Washington to diplomat Henry A. Wise. The meat of the story: a bitter turf war within the Tyler administration over New York's Collectorship—the juiciest patronage prize in the nation. When President Tyler tried to replace longtime Collector Edward Curtis with Charles G. Ferris in April 1844, all hell broke loose. Curtis refused to surrender the seals of office (literally the physical symbol of power), holding out until July. The Whig-controlled Senate blocked the appointment, partly from principle, partly because a faction led by General John P. Van Ness wanted the job for one of their own. The author—signing as Horace Walpole—then goes nuclear, detailing how government employees were forced to subscribe to pro-Tyler newspapers like the 'Union' and 'Aurora,' essentially a protection racket run from the Custom House. Naval Storekeeper Paul R. George managed the 'Union' behind the scenes while Major M. M. Noah served as public editor. When George wouldn't fall in line, the Van Ness faction turned the 'Aurora' newspaper into a weapon to destroy him—a case study in using the press as political cudgel.
Why It Matters
This letter captures the spoils system at its most naked and vicious. The 1840s were the era when American politics ran entirely on patronage—your party won an election, you got to hand out every government job from customs collector to naval storekeeper to sympathetic allies. John Tyler's presidency (1841-1845) was uniquely chaotic: he'd inherited the office when William Henry Harrison died just 32 days in, alienating both Whigs and Democrats. This created a vacuum where competing factions fought savagely over the few plums available. The 'blackmail' Walpole describes—forcing subordinates to buy subscriptions to party newspapers or lose their jobs—was standard practice, but admitting it in print was scandal. This piece documents the machinery of mid-century machine politics before the Civil War would begin reshaping American governance.
Hidden Gems
- The Sunday Dispatch itself cost three cents per week to city subscribers—or one dollar a year by mail. This means a weekly reader paid roughly 1.5 cents per issue, while mail subscribers paid about 0.3 cents per issue. Postage and distribution created brutal economics for newspaper growth.
- Paul R. George held the position of Naval Storekeeper at the Brooklyn Navy Yard—described as 'very much of a sinecure.' This wasn't some minor clerk job; it was important enough that the author notes local Brooklyn citizens were furious about his appointment and wanted his predecessor Colonel Craven restored. Government positions actually mattered to communities.
- The author claims that Custom House officers at salaries ranging from '$fifteen to twenty-five hundred dollars' were taxed to fund the 'Union' newspaper—meaning government workers earning $15-2,500 annually were forced to contribute to party press. A $1,500 salary in 1844 was roughly equivalent to $50,000 today, so this wasn't chump change being squeezed from middle-class bureaucrats.
- Major M. M. Noah appears as editor of the 'Union' despite fierce opposition from a rival 'Graham clique.' Noah was a real historical figure—a journalist, playwright, and early Zionist who'd previously edited the *New York Enquirer*. The fact that his editorship became a proxy battle in Tyler administration infighting shows how central newspapers were to political power.
- The author explicitly defends Edward Curtis against charges of 'levying blackmail,' insisting the reverse was true and that Curtis 'notified individuals who were near him, that if they supposed they were doing him a favor by assailing the Whig party, they erred most egregiously.' This is a politician defending another politician's honor in print—a gesture that feels almost quaint.
Fun Facts
- Daniel Webster appears in this letter as Secretary of State under Tyler—the author mentions the 'Aurora' published 'a most atrocious libel on Mr. Webster.' Webster was one of the era's most powerful senators and would become a giant of pre-Civil War politics, but in 1843-44 he was tangled up in Tyler administration chaos. He'd serve as Secretary of State again under Harrison's successor William Henry Harrison in 1841 and would later argue the Compromise of 1850 cases before the Supreme Court.
- The letter references the 'Harrison Hard Cider Campaign'—the 1840 presidential election that brought William Henry Harrison to office with the famous 'Tippecanoe and Tyler Too' slogan. The author notes the Van Ness faction 'had somewhat distinguished themselves' in that campaign. Harrison's death just 31 days into his term created the succession crisis that made Tyler president and triggered the factional wars this letter describes.
- The 'Union' newspaper was bankrolled by subscription from government employees and office-seekers, with Curtis contributing $500, William Tuggard (Surveyor of the Port) giving $200, and 'some dozen or ten men' handing over portions of their $1,500-2,500 annual salaries. This was how parties funded newspapers before anything resembling campaign finance regulation existed—essentially a tax on everyone who wanted to keep their government job.
- The author claims to have written previous letters in this series ('Chapter 13')—suggesting the Sunday Dispatch was serializing this political drama as ongoing narrative journalism. Readers would have been following this Gothic tale of Washington intrigue week by week, with each installment promising to reveal more names and dirty details about who really controlled the Tyler administration.
- Paul R. George's ultimate fate was sealed when the 'Aurora'—a supposedly 'neutral' newspaper trying to mimic the business model of the New York Herald—was purchased by the anti-George faction specifically to destroy him. The author notes the 'Aurora' had 'not, at any time, manifested any inclination to participate in the politics of the day,' yet it was weaponized anyway. This shows how easily neutral commercial press could be bought and converted into political assault vehicles.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free