Thursday
March 12, 1846
Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis) — Marion, Indiana
“Oregon or War? 1846 Indiana Editors Demand 'The Whole' Territory from Britain”
Art Deco mural for March 12, 1846
Original newspaper scan from March 12, 1846
Original front page — Indiana State sentinel (Indianapolis) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Indiana State Sentinel leads with Democratic nominations for state office—James Whitcomb for Governor and Paris Dunning for Lieutenant Governor—but the paper's real firepower is aimed at the Oregon territorial dispute with Britain. A lengthy editorial, reprinted from the Philadelphia Ledger, argues forcefully against arbitration, warning that any compromise would hand Britain valuable Pacific ports. The piece reads like a war cry: "Let us keep the whole of Oregon, and prepare to defend it." Meanwhile, Congress is taking action on internal improvements, amending House rules to vote on expenditures item-by-item rather than bundling them together—a direct response to past "log-rolling" that wasted millions on useless projects. The paper also reports dramatic news from Virginia: a fatal duel between two newspaper editors, John Pleasants and William Ritchie, fought with pistols, swords, and bowie knives, with Ritchie slashing Pleasants fatally across the abdomen after they closed to hand-to-hand combat.

Why It Matters

This page captures America in a fever pitch over Manifest Destiny. The Oregon Territory dispute—whether the U.S. or Britain would control the Pacific Northwest—was one of the defining geopolitical crises of the 1840s, and Indiana newspapers were mobilizing public opinion for an aggressive stance. Simultaneously, Congress was wrestling with how to fund infrastructure without falling into patronage traps, a battle between Whig and Democratic visions of federal power. The duel between newspaper editors also reflects the volatile, honor-obsessed political culture of the era, where editors weren't just observers—they were combatants willing to kill and die over political insults. This was democracy in its rawest form.

Hidden Gems
  • The Madison and Indianapolis Railroad has just declared a 10 percent dividend—described as 'equal to the very best roads at the east'—and capitalists are buying stock freely. The paper predicts it will be 'one of the most profitable roads in the whole country' once it reaches Indianapolis in about a year. This was a genuine frontier investment boom.
  • A British bark named the Ida was recently wrecked at sea with forty-five people perished—mentioned almost in passing, with no fanfare or investigation. Maritime disasters were so common they barely warranted headline treatment.
  • The paper complains that Indianapolis has had only one dray (a low cart for hauling) in town until this week, and it belonged to 'an honorable member of the Legislature' as 'the sign of his profession'—a hint at the man's humble origins or disreputable background. The editor suggests the town's rapid growth means there's money to be made in hauling freight.
  • Subscription rates are listed: one copy for the year costs $2.00, but ten copies go for $10, and twenty copies to one address run $20. Bulk subscriptions for political organizing and distribution were a real business model.
  • The paper's eastern advertising agent is W.B. Palmer, with offices in New York (Tribune Buildings, opposite City Hall), Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Boston—indicating the Sentinel had national reach and distribution networks in major cities.
Fun Facts
  • James Whitcomb, nominated here for Indiana Governor, would actually win the election and serve two terms (1846–1853). He later served in the U.S. Senate and opposed the Kansas-Nebraska Act, putting him at odds with the expansionism rhetoric dominating this very newspaper in 1846.
  • The Oregon dispute mentioned here would be resolved just two years later, in 1848, when the U.S. and Britain agreed to the 49th parallel as the border—not quite the 'whole of Oregon' the editor demanded, but a significant American victory that opened vast territory to settlement.
  • The fatal duel between Pleasants and Ritchie actually happened in September 1845 (this March 1846 article is reporting 'recent' news), and it was one of the last notable political duels in America. Within a generation, dueling would be virtually extinct in the U.S., replaced by legal proceedings and newspaper libel suits.
  • The paper mentions Gen. Ashley's bill to require Congressional laws be published in state newspapers—a democratic transparency measure. This was genuinely controversial; some politicians wanted to keep government business obscure, while others saw publication as essential to an informed citizenry.
  • The Madison and Indianapolis Railroad mentioned here was a real early railroad that helped transform Indiana's economy. By the 1850s, Indiana would be crisscrossed with rails, making it a transportation hub and attracting manufacturing. That 10% dividend was real wealth creation in a largely agricultural state.
Contentious Progressive Era Politics Federal Politics State Diplomacy War Conflict Crime Violent
March 11, 1846 March 13, 1846

Also on March 12

1836
Inside Washington's Slave Market: How Bondage Was Sold Alongside Spring...
Daily national intelligencer (Washington City [D.C.])
1856
250 Enslaved People for Sale in Washington's Newspaper: A Nation Divided (March...
The daily union (Washington [D.C.])
1861
One Month Before Shots Fired: Memphis Newspapers Show America Still Hoping...
Memphis daily appeal (Memphis, Tenn.)
1862
Want 10,000 Ladies & Desperately Need Soldiers: March 1862's Collision of War &...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1863
A General Refuses to Fight (Until Lincoln Frees the Slaves): The Cassius Clay...
Weekly national intelligencer (Washington [D.C.])
1864
Lee Met McClellan in Secret—And Now He's Setting the Record Straight (March...
Worcester daily spy (Worcester [Mass.])
1866
One Year After Appomattox: A Union Officer's Brutal Testimony on the...
Chicago tribune (Chicago, Ill.)
1876
When Dwight Moody Met His Match: A Jewish Scholar's Brilliant Takedown (1876)
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1886
A Young Senator Shocks the Capital: How Cleveland's Appointment Powers Sparked...
The Washington critic (Washington, D.C.)
1896
A Farmer's Furious Return: Why This South Dakotan Fled the South and Never...
Turner County herald (Hurley, Dakota [S.D.])
1906
Death in Indian Territory: When Federal Marshals Met Cherokee Outlaws in 1906
The Topeka state journal (Topeka, Kansas)
1926
When Sweden told Britain 'You're trying to bully us' and started a diplomatic...
Evening star (Washington, D.C.)
1927
Hidden History: How U.S. Labor Leaders Let 100+ Cuban Workers Die in Silence...
The daily worker (Chicago, Ill.;New York, N.Y.)
View all 13 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free