What's on the Front Page
The Daily Union's front page on March 7, 1846, captures a Washington society humming with cultural refinement and commercial enterprise. Two farewell entertainments dominate the social calendar: Mr. Dempster, a vocalist returning to Europe, performs selections from Robert Burns at Corusi's Saloon on Monday evening, offering songs like "The Poosie" and "Mary in Heaven" for 50 cents admission. The following night, violinist Joseph Burke gives his farewell concert, performing variations on "Carnival of Venice" and other classical pieces for $1 a ticket. Yet beneath the refined concert announcements lies a congressional firestorm: Representative Rhett of South Carolina delivers a lengthy constitutional argument against a federal internal improvements bill that would appropriate millions for harbors and rivers—money flowing almost entirely north and west. Rhett argues the measure violates states' rights and the original intent of the 1787 Northwest Ordinance, claiming the federal government has no jurisdiction over western rivers. The South, he declares bitterly, "will follow the hearse, as a mourner, to its last home" of constitutional principles betrayed by the very party that invented them.
Why It Matters
This page captures America in the heated debate over federal power that would ultimately fracture the nation. The 1840s saw the Second Great Awakening's enthusiasm for progress clash head-on with strict constitutional interpretation. Rhett's speech rehearses arguments that would echo through the secession crisis fifteen years later—the conviction that a North-dominated federal government was appropriating powers reserved to states. Internal improvements (canals, roads, harbors) were intensely sectional issues: the West demanded federal investment while the South, lacking navigable rivers and fearing federal overreach, opposed them. Meanwhile, Washington City itself remained a backwater capital, its cultural life dependent on transient congressmen and visiting performers like Dempster and Burke. The contrast between refined imports of European culture and raw constitutional conflict defines the era's contradictions.
Hidden Gems
- An 80-year-old woman in Smithfield, Pennsylvania, regained her hearing after 40 years of progressive deafness using Scarpa's Oil for Deafness—a 'cure' being hawked in Washington by F.W. Fuller, suggesting the city's appetite for dubious medical remedies was as strong as its love of constitutional debate.
- Spring fashion alert: M.H. Stevens & Emmons hatters, formerly Fish & Co., are introducing 'Leary & Co.'s much admired spring style' on March 7, 1846—the very day this paper was printed—with one partner having just returned from New York bearing the 'very latest' in hat crown form, brim style, and trimmings.
- Dr. Jackson's Pile Embrocation has allegedly achieved such universal success that even the Boston firm Carter, Wilson & Co. confirms it 'gives universal satisfaction'—the irony of a hemorrhoid cure advertisement appearing adjacent to passionate constitutional arguments about federal power is almost certainly unintentional.
- Plumbe's National Daguerreotype Gallery, established in 1840 and winner of multiple medals and 'highest honors' from Massachusetts, New York, and Pennsylvania, operated a portrait studio at Concert Hall on Pennsylvania Avenue—offering photographic services 'in any weather in exquisite style' with 'apparatus, instructions, and all materials furnished,' suggesting early competitive aggression in the daguerreotype market.
- J.F. Callan's agricultural implement store at Corner E and 7th Street advertises 'the largest assortment in the District' of plows, cultivators, corn-shellers, straw-cutters, and other farm equipment—evidence that even the nation's capital maintained a working agricultural sector dependent on hand tools.
Fun Facts
- Robert Burns, whose songs fill Mr. Dempster's farewell program, had died just 51 years earlier in 1796—making this 1846 performance part of a 19th-century Burns revival that would culminate in his elevation to national bard status. Burns Suppers celebrating his birthday are still held worldwide today.
- Rhett's constitutional argument about the 1787 Northwest Ordinance was already 59 years old and had been settled law, yet he resurrects it with fury—this same Rhett would become a leading South Carolina fire-eater and secessionist, signing the ordinance of secession in 1860, making this speech a prophetic warning of coming catastrophe.
- Joseph Burke performing 'Carnival of Venice' variations on March 10, 1846, was one of the era's most celebrated violinists—yet today he's almost entirely forgotten, erased by recorded music and the rise of symphony orchestras that rendered traveling concert stars obsolete within decades.
- The advertisement for Glenn's Compound Spermaceti Soap for chapped hands reveals that 1840s Washington winters were considered a legitimate public health concern—the mere mention suggests the city had no central heating, and even wealthy citizens suffered seasonal skin afflictions we'd now consider minor.
- Plumbe's daguerreotype studios operated in nine cities (Washington, Baltimore, Petersburg, New York, Boston, Philadelphia, Cincinnati, Louisville, Lexington, St. Louis, and Saratoga Springs), making it a genuinely national portrait enterprise—yet within a decade, the daguerreotype itself would be obsolete, replaced by wet collodion photography.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free