“How a Fiery Arkansas Congressman Nearly Started a War Over 'Every Foot' of Oregon—1846”
What's on the Front Page
The Daily Union's front page is dominated by a lengthy Congressional speech from Representative Archibald Yell of Arkansas, delivered February 7, 1846, on a resolution authorizing President Polk to give notice terminating joint occupancy of the Oregon Territory. Yell's passionate address argues that American title to Oregon is ironclad—dating back to the Louisiana Purchase of 1803, which gave the U.S. claim to all land west of the Mississippi and Rocky Mountains. He methodically dismantles British claims rooted in the 1790 Nootka Sound Convention, contending Britain acquired only trading rights, not sovereignty. The speech is notably bipartisan: Yell, a Democrat, praises his alignment with Massachusetts Whig John Quincy Adams on this "great American platform." He dismisses the "masterly inactivity" of previous administrations, arguing the situation has changed because thousands of American citizens now inhabit Oregon and demand protection. Yell insists that if America's title is good, "we would have every foot of it, or a fig it"—no compromise with Britain or any power.
Why It Matters
This speech captures the fever pitch of American expansionism in 1846—the year that would see both the Oregon Treaty with Britain and the declaration of war against Mexico. The "Oregon Question" was existential: Did America's western border end at the Rocky Mountains, or did it stretch all the way to the 54°40' parallel (present-day Alaska)? Yell's invocation of American settlers already occupying the territory reflected the broader ideology of Manifest Destiny: the belief that American expansion westward was inevitable and justified. The resolution he championed ultimately led to negotiations that would fix the border at the 49th parallel—a compromise many Western expansionists considered a betrayal. This moment represents America on the brink of doubling its territory through aggressive diplomacy and, shortly thereafter, war.
Hidden Gems
- The newspaper announces its own publishing schedule adjustments: "The country paper will be published tri-weekly during the sessions of Congress, and semi-weekly during the recess"—showing how the rhythms of government literally shaped newspaper production in the 19th century.
- Payment rules for subscriptions reveal the era's financial chaos: "The notes of any specie paying bank will be received" for subscriptions or advertisements—meaning newspapers had to manually assess whether bank notes from different states and institutions were actually valuable.
- Yell's citation of the 1819 Convention between the U.S. and Britain includes a strikingly precise boundary definition: a line from "the most northern point of the Lake of the Woods, along the water's parallels of north latitude"—18th-century diplomats solving 21st-century geographic challenges with the precision instruments available to them.
- The speech references correspondence about Fort George's restoration after the War of 1812, dated October 8, 1818, signed by Captain R. Barclay and J. B. Stewart of the Northwest Company—showing how Oregon territorial claims were entangled with post-war settlement agreements.
- Yell notes General Jackson pursued "inactivity" on Oregon extension because "there were then no people in the territory for the laws to operate upon"—a strikingly honest admission that U.S. sovereignty claims were only activated once settler presence demanded it.
Fun Facts
- Archibald Yell himself would be killed in combat just two years later, in 1848, fighting in the Mexican-American War he championed—one of the few sitting U.S. Representatives to die in military service.
- The 1819 Convention Yell cites extensively would be superseded just 27 years after this speech by the 1846 Oregon Treaty, which essentially gave Britain the territory north of the 49th parallel and the U.S. everything south—settling the "54°40' or Fight" dispute that nearly pulled America into war with Britain.
- John Quincy Adams, the Massachusetts Whig whom Yell praises here for supporting the Oregon notice, was 78 years old at this speech and serving in Congress—he would die just two years later, in 1848, having spent his post-presidency as a representative, an almost unique trajectory in American politics.
- The Nootka Sound Convention of 1790 that Yell discusses was itself a crisis averted—it nearly sparked war between Britain and Spain over Pacific fur-trading rights and represented the kind of imperial jockeying that would shape American expansion debates for decades.
- By giving this notice in 1846, Polk was essentially calling Britain's bluff on joint occupancy; Britain would concede rather than fight, but the very fact that America needed to issue notice shows how contested western territory was—settlers were moving there faster than governments could claim it.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free