“"The Whole of Oregon!" How Congress Nearly Went to War with Britain Over Empty Wilderness (1846)”
What's on the Front Page
The Daily Union publishes Congressman Thompson of Pennsylvania's lengthy floor speech defending President Polk's Oregon Territory resolution, delivered January 29, 1846. Thompson argues passionately against war predictions, insisting that giving Britain twelve months' notice to terminate their joint occupation of Oregon will not spark conflict. "There is no war in this," he declares, pointing to the peaceful press commentary in England and the Queen's silence on the matter. Thompson systematically dismantles the war-mongering rhetoric, examining the Nootka Sound Convention of 1790 and the treaties of 1818 and 1827 that established joint occupancy. He contends that Britain recognized American possession of the territory, so if notice is given, Britain "must move first" to claim rights—putting any potential aggressor in the wrong. Thompson closes with a rousing declaration: "I will stand for the whole of Oregon, and the tariff too!" The speech showcases the heated parliamentary debate consuming Washington as the nation faces its most serious foreign crisis in decades.
Why It Matters
This speech occurs during the "Oregon Crisis," one of the most explosive territorial disputes in early American history. The U.S. and Britain jointly occupied the Oregon Territory under an indefinite agreement, but American expansionists demanded the entire region (claiming it stretched to the 54°40' parallel—"Fifty-Four Forty or Fight" was the campaign slogan). The debate between war hawks and diplomats like Thompson would ultimately resolve with the Oregon Treaty of 1846, establishing the 49th parallel as the border. This moment represents America at a crossroads: between empire-building aggression and measured diplomacy. The outcome would determine whether the U.S. expanded peacefully or through armed conflict with Britain, America's largest trading partner and naval superpower.
Hidden Gems
- The newspaper advertises subscription rates and explicitly states it will be "published tri weekly during the session of Congress, and but weekly during the recess"—revealing how congressional schedules literally shaped publication frequency in 1846.
- Thompson references President Adams's 1826 recommendation to erect a fort at the mouth of the Columbia River at Cape Disappointment (on the north side), proving this Oregon conflict had been simmering for 20 years before exploding into a crisis.
- The speech quotes directly from the Nootka Sound Convention of 1790, including Article 3's remarkably detailed language about "fisheries" and "trade with natives"—showing how 56-year-old treaty language was being weaponized in current political battle.
- Thompson casually invokes the "Tempest in a tea-pot" metaphor, suggesting some in Congress thought the whole Oregon dispute was overblown drama—yet this would bring America to the brink of war with the British Empire.
- The newspaper's masthead declares "LIBERTY, THE UNION, AND THE CONSTITUTION"—reflecting the Jacksonian Democratic slogan dominating political discourse, with Thompson using these very principles to argue against warmongering.
Fun Facts
- Thompson's speech cites Sir Robert Peel as England's leader defending British "rights" in Oregon—yet Peel would be forced from power just months later (June 1846) over the Corn Laws repeal, making him politically vulnerable on territorial questions just as this crisis peaked.
- Thompson argues that giving notice is 'not a war measure' based on how the English press received it—he was right. The Oregon Treaty was signed peacefully in June 1846, just four months after this speech, proving diplomatic notice could resolve imperial disputes without bloodshed.
- The congressman insists England cannot justify war because America is 'in possession' of Oregon, citing Secretary of State Buchanan's arguments—Buchanan would himself become President in 1857 and face the even more explosive Kansas-Nebraska crisis over slavery territories.
- Thompson's passionate declaration 'I will stand for the whole of Oregon, and the tariff too!' connected territorial expansion to trade policy—the tariff debate would dominate American politics for the next 15 years and contribute to Southern secession anxieties.
- The speech extensively quotes from the 1790 Nootka Sound Convention regarding Spanish territorial claims—Spain had already lost most of its American empire by 1846, yet the ghosts of 18th-century European imperial disputes still haunted American westward expansion policy.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free