“1846: When Counterfeit Medicine Was a Capital Crime (in the Court of Public Opinion)”
What's on the Front Page
The front page of the New Hampshire Gazette is dominated by a passionate defense of Wright's Indian Vegetable Pills against counterfeiters—a raging editorial that reads like a 19th-century consumer protection manifesto. The piece warns that fraudulent versions of this hugely popular patent medicine are flooding the market, often sold by "respectable druggists" willing to peddle fake pills for profit. The rhetoric is fierce: "The counterfeiter of a popular medicine is more criminal than the counter feiter of current money," the writer declares, conjuring images of invalids dying from worthless substitutes when the genuine cure might have saved them. The ad provides detailed authentication marks—specific wording on boxes, copyright notices from 1840, and a network of authorized agents across New Hampshire, with Nathaniel March of Exchange Buildings serving as Portsmouth's sole legitimate dealer. Below this, competitor patent medicines advertise their own cures: Dr. John D. Buzzell's Family Medicines promise relief from everything from jaundice to dropsy, while another vendor hawks pills as "the most Invaluable Family Medicine Known," tested for over forty years. The page also announces new literary arrivals—Littell's Living Age (endorsed by no less than John Quincy Adams) and Fremont's Narrative of the Exploring Expedition to the Rocky Mountains, Oregon and California.
Why It Matters
In 1846, America had no FDA, no drug regulation, and no systematic way to distinguish real medicine from snake oil. Patent medicines were the nation's fastest-growing industry, and counterfeiting was rampant because the profit margins were enormous and punishment light. This front page reveals the desperation of honest medicine makers to protect their brands in a lawless marketplace—and exposes how pharmaceutical fraud was already a serious public health crisis before the Civil War. The emphasis on authorized dealers and certificates of agency shows early attempts at branding and distribution control that prefigured modern pharmaceutical business practices. Meanwhile, the advertisements for literary works and the Fremont expedition narrative reflect the era's hunger for knowledge and westward expansion—1846 was the year of the Oregon Territory dispute and the Mexican-American War's opening salvos.
Hidden Gems
- John Quincy Adams himself endorsed Littell's Living Age in a personal letter dated December 27, 1845, calling it "the most useful" periodical devoted to literature and science—yet today this magazine is completely forgotten, while his presidency is legendary.
- Wright's Pills cost 25 cents per box, with each box described as equivalent to a 'complete Medicine Chest'—a remarkable claim when the average worker earned about $1 per day, making medicine roughly a quarter of daily wages.
- The ad warns customers to 'Beware of the Infected District in Union Street, Boston'—suggesting that counterfeiting was so concentrated in certain neighborhoods that they could be identified by name to alert consumers.
- Nathaniel March, Portsmouth's authorized agent, operated from 'No. 7 Exchange Buildings' and also sold blank books, memorandums, and journals—the paper notes he could undercut traveling peddlers on prices, revealing how local merchants competed with the growing culture of itinerant salesmen.
- The North American College of Health, which issued credentials for Wright's Pills, appears to have been a private credentialing body rather than an academic institution—part of the murky world of early patent medicine 'colleges' that granted dubious medical authority.
Fun Facts
- Wright's Indian Vegetable Pills were so successful that they spawned an entire ecosystem of counterfeits by 1846—this phenomenon would eventually lead to the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906, the first major federal regulation of patent medicines, exactly 60 years after this newspaper.
- The Fremont Narrative advertised on this page for 25 cents was from John C. Frémont's 1842-1844 western expedition; Frémont would become a presidential candidate in 1856 and help launch the Republican Party—his explorations directly fueled westward expansion debates raging in 1846.
- Littell's Living Age, endorsed here by John Quincy Adams (who died just 8 months after writing this letter in June 1846), was America's first successful reprint magazine, importing the best British and European periodicals—it would remain in continuous publication until 1941.
- The Botanic Medicines depot in Boston advertised here represented the alternative medical movement of the era; Samuel Thomson's Botanic System (which opposed mercury and bloodletting) was in direct competition with conventional doctors, a schism that defined American medicine throughout the 19th century.
- Portsmouth's thriving retail culture shown in these ads—from patent medicines to fancy goods to boots and shoes—reflects New Hampshire's role as a prosperous maritime trading hub, though the city would lose economic prominence after railroads bypassed it in the 1850s.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free