“"Don't Fight Yet"—A Congressman's Bold Plan to Win Oregon Without Firing a Shot (Jan. 21, 1846)”
What's on the Front Page
The Daily Union's front page features an extended congressional speech by Representative Seddinger of Virginia on the Oregon Territory dispute with Great Britain. Seddinger passionately argues against immediately terminating the joint occupation agreement, despite acknowledging America's clear legal title to the disputed land. The core tension: while admitting "Oregon is ours—every acre, every poor road of it," Seddinger urges Congress to hold fire rather than "throw down the gauntlet" to Britain over the territory. Instead, he proposes aggressive domestic action: establish a territorial government immediately, appoint a governor, erect American forts and blockhouses along the Oregon Trail, appoint Indian agents, establish an overland mail route, and encourage mass emigration. His strategy is patient occupation—letting American settlers flood in and establish facts on the ground. He cites predictions that 10,000 settlers will populate Oregon before Congress adjourns, arguing that within five years, American homesteaders will be so numerous "no power upon earth" could wrest the territory away. Seddinger's speech represents the rising voices pushing for "Manifest Destiny"—expansion through settlement rather than immediate military confrontation.
Why It Matters
In 1846, the Oregon Territory question embodied America's westward expansion fever and the tensions with Britain over North American dominance. The dispute centered on whether the US-Canada border would run at the 49th parallel (splitting Oregon) or further north at 54°40', spurring the "54-40 or Fight" political slogan. Seddinger's speech captures a pivotal moment: young America was growing confident enough to challenge the world's naval superpower, yet pragmatic enough to prefer demographic conquest over military conflict. This debate would shape US foreign policy and ultimately lead to the 1846 Oregon Treaty, establishing the modern US-Canada border. The speech also reveals how Americans justified westward expansion—not as colonialism, but as inevitable settlement by free citizens claiming "empty" lands, conveniently overlooking Native American populations.
Hidden Gems
- Seddinger casually references that the Hudson Bay Company's fur trade 'is diminishing rapidly'—he's essentially predicting the economic irrelevance of the fur trade within years, which would indeed collapse as industrialization and westward settlement made beaver skins less valuable than land itself.
- The speech mentions 7,000 American settlers already in Oregon when Congress began its session, with expectations of 10,000 by adjournment—these concrete numbers show how rapid American emigration was happening organically, without government protection, suggesting the settlement strategy Seddinger championed was already underway.
- Seddinger addresses an objection from 'Mr. Owen' (another Indiana congressman) that American emigration would never extend north of the Columbia River or latitude 49°—this reveals the geographic confusion and genuine uncertainty about which parts of Oregon were actually settable and valuable, despite the confident legal claims.
- The paper's masthead declares its principles: 'LIBERTY, THE UNION, AND THE CONSTITUTION'—a telling trinity that captures Democratic-Republican ideology of the 1840s, with 'The Union' positioned between liberty and constitutional law, suggesting preservation of American unity was a central preoccupation.
- Seddinger invokes the biblical phrase 'tarry at Jericho till our beards shall grow out,' repurposing scripture to argue Americans should wait patiently for settlement to deliver Oregon—revealing how religious language sanctified westward expansion as providential, not merely political.
Fun Facts
- Seddinger's speech references Secretary of State correspondence with British ministers about Oregon's legal claims—this was likely Secretary James K. Polk's diplomacy, and Polk would be elected President just months after this speech (November 1846), bringing an even more aggressive expansionist to the White House who would soon push for war with Mexico over Texas.
- The 49th parallel border that Seddinger mentions as a compromise offer became the actual US-Canada boundary when the Oregon Treaty was signed in June 1846—just five months after this speech. Seddinger's 'patient occupation' strategy essentially won: the treaty gave America everything south of the 49th parallel without war.
- Seddinger's call for an overland mail route and forts along the Oregon Trail foreshadowed the Pony Express (1860-1861) and the transcontinental railroad (completed 1869)—infrastructure projects that would make his vision of mass settlement actually possible within a generation.
- The speech was printed in The Daily Union, a Democratic-leaning paper edited by Thomas Ritchie—Ritchie was one of the most influential political editors in America and would use his platform to champion Polk's expansionist agenda, making newspapers like this genuine power brokers in US foreign policy.
- Seddinger's confidence that 10,000 settlers could defend Oregon against the Hudson Bay Company reflects the era's belief in American civic militias—within 15 years, the Civil War would shatter that myth, revealing that untrained settlers were no match for professional armies, fundamentally changing how America thought about military power.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free