Tuesday
October 4, 1836
Richmond enquirer (Richmond, Va.) — Virginia, Richmond
“1836: When Presidential Candidates Bet Real Money on Election Results”
Mural Unavailable
Original newspaper scan from October 4, 1836
Original front page — Richmond enquirer (Richmond, Va.) — Click to enlarge
Full-size newspaper scan
What's on the Front Page

The Richmond Enquirer's front page is dominated by a fiery political debate over the 1836 presidential election, featuring a series of bold wagers challenging federal newspaper editors to put their money where their mouths are. A correspondent identified as "J.M." from Washington has submitted multiple betting propositions—some as high as $3,000—wagering that Democrat Martin Van Buren will decisively defeat his Whig rivals William Henry Harrison, Hugh L. White, and Daniel Webster. The challenger even claims Van Buren will receive double, triple, or four times as many electoral votes as his opponents combined. These aren't idle boasts: the bets are backed by real money to be deposited in Washington banks, with stakes to be settled after Election Day. The Enquirer's editors mock federal opposition papers for publishing electoral projections they themselves don't believe, calling them "barefaced" lies. This heated exchange captures the raw partisan intensity of an election that would prove far closer than Van Buren's supporters anticipated.

Why It Matters

October 1836 fell in the thick of one of America's most tumultuous electoral moments. Andrew Jackson's presidency was ending, and the Democratic establishment was betting everything on Van Buren's succession—a transfer of power that many Americans viewed as a dangerous dynastic consolidation. The Whig Party, barely a decade old, was mounting a serious challenge by fielding multiple regional candidates to deny Van Buren an electoral majority. The financial panic of 1837 was just months away, and voters were increasingly restless about economic instability. These wagers reveal how polarized the nation had become: money-backed predictions published in newspapers weren't just expressions of opinion, they were instruments of political intimidation and confidence-building.

Hidden Gems
  • One bettor openly challenges "the whole kit" of opposition candidates against a staggering $50,000 wager that Van Buren will win, with specific instructions that the stakes be 'negotiated in some of the specie-paying tracks of the U.S.' by October 1st—revealing that by 1836, many American banks were already failing to redeem paper currency, forcing serious bettors to demand actual gold or silver.
  • A classical teacher wanted ad in Talbot, Georgia offers escalating annual salaries: $500 the first year, $750 the second, and $1,000 by the third year—provided the teacher commits to staying. The ad explicitly warns off short-term hires, suggesting that schools were hemorrhaging teachers who treated the job as temporary, a problem that plagued rural Southern education.
  • A runaway slave advertisement for 'Edmund Kinney' describes him as so light-skinned that 'few persons would suspect his being a slave, and probably he will pass as a white man'—a chilling reminder that the Virginia slavery market depended on visual categorization, and that the color line itself was legally constructed and brutally enforced.
  • The Newmarket horse auction advertised includes bloodstock descended from 'Old Pacolet and Isabella' being sold at public auction in October, with the breeder claiming they're 'equal to any other in the United States.' Horse racing was the sport of both Southern planters and Northern gentlemen—the one arena where sectional rivalries played out without political rancor.
  • A female seminary in Petersburg promises instruction in 'Government of the United States' alongside painting and embroidery, charging $20 for English branches and $75 for board—evidence that even in 1836, educated Southern women were receiving serious civic instruction, though they could neither vote nor own property.
Fun Facts
  • The Enquirer was published 'twice a week, generally, and during the session of the State Legislature'—meaning Richmond's political calendar literally determined the newspaper's publication schedule. When the legislature adjourned, the news cycle effectively shut down.
  • Van Buren would ultimately WIN the 1836 election with 170 electoral votes, but his margin was far narrower than these confident wagerers predicted—he won only 50.8% of the popular vote, and the Whigs' strategy of fielding regional candidates nearly worked. The economy collapsed just weeks into his presidency, making him a one-term president haunted by forces beyond his control.
  • Daniel Webster, one of the three Whig candidates mentioned, was simultaneously serving as a U.S. Senator and a presidential candidate—a practice that seems unthinkable today but was routine in the 1830s, reflecting how loosely the separation of powers was observed.
  • The ad for blooded stock at Newmarket from William Wynn emphasizes that he's selling due to 'bad health' and because he's 'anxious to sell, even if it shall be effected by valuation'—a poignant reminder that the 1830s had no circuit breakers for personal financial disaster, and that wealth in horses could evaporate quickly.
  • The classical teacher position offering $1,000 annually by year three was roughly equivalent to $35,000 in modern currency, yet the Trustees felt compelled to justify it as 'a handsome salary'—revealing that rural Southern education budgets were genuinely constrained, and that retaining qualified instructors required real financial incentive.
Contentious Politics Federal Election Economy Banking Civil Rights Education
October 2, 1836 October 6, 1836

Also on October 4

1846
Potatoes Rotting Across Europe, Empires Fracturing: Oct. 4, 1846
The New York herald (New York [N.Y.])
1856
What Congress Paid for in 1856 (And Why It Matters Before the Civil War)
Daily Iowa State Democrat (Davenport, Iowa)
1861
A Maryland merchant's wife learns gratitude in October 1861—while the Civil War...
Montgomery County sentinel (Rockville, Md.)
1862
Can the Union Finish What Maryland Started? A War at the Crossroads, October...
Springfield weekly Republican (Springfield, Mass.)
1863
A Union Spy's Last Words on the Richmond Gallows—and the Desperate Wartime...
New York dispatch (New York [N.Y.])
1864
Richmond Falls? Union Cavalry Routs Rebels as Sherman Advances and Price...
The sun (New York [N.Y.])
1865
1865: Baltimore Workers March for 8-Hour Days While Reconstruction Stumbles...
Baltimore daily commercial (Baltimore, Md.)
1866
Kansas Paper Roasts President Johnson: 'You Cannot Cheat the People, John'...
White Cloud Kansas chief (White Cloud, Kan.)
1876
1876: How Druggists Fit Surgical Trusses & Other Forgotten Services—Plus Wall...
Daily Kennebec journal (Augusta, Me.)
1886
When Wine Cellars & Alfalfa Built California: A Land Boom Front Page from 1886
Sacramento daily record-union (Sacramento [Calif.])
1896
1896: A Congressman Warns America Against 'Cheap Money'—and Three Masked Men...
New-York tribune (New York [N.Y.])
1906
1906: Free Train Rides to Buy Pianos & A Small-Town Editor's Epic Feud
The Loup City northwestern (Loup City, Neb.)
1926
The Wedding Day Murder & D.C. Stephenson's Prison Roommate
The Indianapolis times (Indianapolis [Ind.])
1927
Small-Town America at a Crossroads: Pleasantville's $635K School Debt Divides a...
The Pleasantville press (Pleasantville, N.J.)
View all 14 years →

Wake Up to History

Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.

Subscribe Free