What's on the Front Page
The front page is dominated by a lengthy, scathing speech from Representative Joseph Underwood of Kentucky, delivered on May 23, 1836, during House debate over the Fortification Bill. Rather than discussing military defenses, Underwood launches into a blistering partisan attack, accusing President Andrew Jackson's Democratic Party of abandoning republican principles and morphing into what he calls the 'sop party'—a reference to Judas Iscariot's betrayal. He argues that Democrats have become 'worshippers of elective despotism' who use 'corrupt and bribed press' editors to deceive the public and 'play upon the prejudices and credulity of mankind.' The speech pivots to a technical defense of distributing the federal government's massive budget surplus—$33 million sitting in deposit banks—among the states. Underwood argues the treasury will remain flush with revenue from tariffs and western land sales, pointing to booming settlement in territories that were wilderness during the War of 1812. He paints a vivid picture of westward expansion: frontier log cabins transformed into prosperous farms, newly wealthy farmers now able to purchase foreign luxuries, steamboats crowding western waterways.
Why It Matters
This speech captures the raw partisan fury of the 1830s, when America's two-party system was crystallizing into its modern form. The Democrats under Jackson had rebranded from Republicans, and opposition Whigs like Underwood felt betrayed—seeing Jackson's spoils system and executive power as a corruption of republican ideals. The surplus revenue debate was existential: should federal money go to internal improvements, be distributed to states, or retired? This question drove infrastructure debates for decades. Meanwhile, Underwood's extended passage on western growth reveals something crucial about 1836 America—the nation was undergoing explosive territorial expansion, with settlers flooding into territories that Indian Removal was supposed to 'clear,' as Underwood casually mentions 'Indian wars prevailing in Florida, Alabama, and Georgia.' The prosperity he celebrates was built directly on displacement.
Hidden Gems
- Underwood casually mentions $7 million in U.S. Bank stock sitting in the federal treasury—this was the controversial Bank of the United States that Jackson had destroyed the previous year. The fact that the government still held stock shows the financial entanglement was messier than popular narratives suggest.
- He warns of danger from 'six hundred banks' scattered across America with dangerously low specie reserves, explicitly predicting the banking panic of 1819-'20 could recur. This chillingly accurate forecast preceded the actual Panic of 1837 by just nine months—one of the worst financial collapses in American history.
- The subscription price for this newspaper was $10/year ($300+ today)—payable in advance—with an unusual auto-renewal clause stating papers would continue indefinitely unless explicitly discontinued. This was essentially the 1830s version of an auto-renewing subscription trap.
- Underwood compares opposition editors to 'polecats' in a vivid metaphor about how defending oneself against newspaper attacks leaves you 'in bad odour, even with his friends'—early 19th century newspapers were vicious attack dogs, and even responding to them damaged a politician's reputation.
- The speech emphasizes steamboats 'actively engaged upon the waters of the West'—this was the transportation revolution peak. The Erie Canal (completed 1825) and early steamboat networks were transforming commerce, but railroads were just beginning. Within a decade, they'd dominate.
Fun Facts
- Representative Underwood complains bitterly about the 'Globe'—the Democratic Party's official newspaper, edited by Francis Preston Blair. That same Globe would later publish the first interview with Abraham Lincoln as a presidential candidate in 1860, becoming one of the most influential papers in American history.
- Underwood celebrates western expansion by noting farms now yielded 'surplus grain, or tobacco, or cotton, or live stock' for market. He has no idea he's describing the exact conditions that would, within 25 years, make the South's slave-dependent cotton economy so powerful it would nearly tear the nation apart in the Civil War.
- The $33 million surplus he discusses was staggering wealth for 1836—but it was also destined to vanish. The Panic of 1837, occurring just months after this speech, would devastate the economy and eliminate this cushion entirely. Underwood's sunny confidence about perpetual revenue proved premature by mere months.
- His detailed economic analysis assumes tariff revenue would remain robust, but the Compromise Tariff of 1833 he mentions was designed to gradually lower duties. By the 1850s, tariff revenue collapsed, creating federal budget deficits that lasted until the Civil War—making his prediction of 'overflowing' treasuries laughably wrong.
- The speech represents the moment before America's party system fully hardened. Within 4 years, the Whig Party (Underwood's party) would run William Henry Harrison in 1840 and briefly become dominant. By 1854, both Whigs and Democrats would be destroyed over slavery, replaced by Republicans. This fiery partisan battle was happening in the twilight of an entire political era.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free