“Virginia Democrats Erupt: Legislators Accuse Majority of Betraying the People's Will in Van Buren Nomination (1836)”
What's on the Front Page
The front page of the Lynchburg Virginian on April 4, 1836, is dominated by a lengthy political manifesto from Anti-Jacksonian members of Virginia's legislature. Under the heading "ADDRESS TO THE PEOPLE OF VIRGINIA," a minority of representatives issues an urgent warning about threats to republican governance. Their central complaint: a majority of Virginia's legislators has nominated Martin Van Buren for President at the Democratic National Convention in Baltimore—allegedly without consulting their constituents or even disclosing their intentions beforehand. The minority argues this violates a sacred tradition of Virginia politics, where representatives were expected to seek public instruction before making such pivotal decisions. They're particularly incensed that an "inexplicable obligation" to recognize the Baltimore Convention as paramount has overridden the people's will. Interspersed with the political screed are typical advertisements: Westly Ward's dry goods emporium announces "Staple and Fancy Dry Goods, Hardware, Groceries," with an elaborate inventory list; M. Benjamin's ready-made clothing store offers suits and cloaks; and a notice of valuable real estate at auction promises canal access. One ad even announces the owner of 15,000 pounds of lard and offers hackney coaches with "experienced and careful drivers."
Why It Matters
This page captures a pivotal moment in American democratic development—the 1836 presidential election and the Jacksonian era's reshaping of party politics. The minority representatives' fury reveals deep anxiety about how nominations were being made in a still-evolving democratic system. The complaint that a national convention in Baltimore should not override a state legislature's autonomy speaks to tensions between emerging national parties and traditional state-centered politics. Van Buren's nomination represented the Democratic Party's effort to maintain Jackson's political coalition, while the Whigs (Anti-Jacksonian) were coalescing in opposition. Virginia, a crucial swing state and home to the nation's founding political traditions, was a battleground. The legislators' invocation of the people's will and their rage at being bypassed reveals how contested the very *meaning* of representative democracy still was in the 1830s.
Hidden Gems
- The minority representatives rage that the Baltimore Convention was "composed of men, none of whom were delegated by the people, even under the forms of election, and many of whom were there of their own individual accord, without these slightest request or authority from any"—an explicit admission that the "democratic" convention process was actually packed with self-appointed delegates.
- A classified ad mentions the sale of 1,000 pounds of lard alongside "two comfortable HACKS [horse-drawn carriages] with excellent houses, and experienced and careful drivers"—evidence that Lynchburg's merchant class was liquidating assets, possibly fleeing or consolidating businesses during economic uncertainty.
- The newspaper itself cost $3 per annum, paid in advance, and advertisements cost 50 cents per square inch for the first insertion—putting literacy and information access squarely in the hands of the propertied classes who could afford subscriptions.
- A notice announces the postponement of a land auction, stating the property is "valuable" and noteworthy because "the Canal will run through it"—direct evidence of how the James River Canal project was driving real estate speculation and reshaping Virginia's economy.
- The political address itself was "unanimously adopted" by the minority representatives—revealing that this wasn't merely individual dissent but an organized legislative faction mobilizing against the majority's actions.
Fun Facts
- This address was issued by Anti-Jacksonian legislators just four months before the 1836 election. Though they failed to stop Van Buren's nomination, the Whig Party they represented would actually WIN the presidency in 1840 with William Henry Harrison—proving that Virginia's political anxieties reflected real national power shifts happening in real time.
- The representatives invoke Virginia's historical tradition of electing presidents (Washington, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe) and guardianship of republican principles—a claim that was already becoming obsolete. After 1836, no Virginian would be elected president for 28 years, marking the end of Virginia's dominance in national politics.
- The fury over Van Buren's nomination is particularly ironic: Van Buren, Jackson's chosen successor, was himself a New Yorker, not a planter or slaveholder. The real subtext of Virginia's resistance was anxiety about Northern political ascendancy and the declining political weight of the South—tensions that would explode into secession 25 years later.
- The detailed inventory of dry goods ("Extra superfine black," "Plaid Silk Dress," "Cassinets") and the ready-made clothing store reveal that Lynchburg, though a tobacco and canal town, was fully integrated into national consumer capitalism by 1836—goods were arriving from manufacturers in the Northeast and Britain.
- The announcement of Westly Ward's jewelry business, stocked with "Gold and Silver Lever Watches" and "Gold Ear-rings, Breast Pins," and offering "Watches carefully repaired," proves that even in Virginia, luxury consumer goods and the culture of timekeeping were becoming essential markers of middle-class respectability.
Wake Up to History
Every morning: one front page from exactly 100 years ago, with context, hidden gems, and an original Art Deco mural. Free.
Subscribe Free